[Archive]

Posted By: Frank Wakefield

Did you get your money back? Then why neg him?? Learn and move on.


Having reread a bit, why does your heading say "Can this be a PSA 3??" if the grade doesn't matter?

I'm all about buying the card, and I don't have complete faith in the card grading services. I think they screw up more than I do with card identification and authentication. They do it a lot more, I'll give 'em that. And more folks have faith in what they think than what I think, as evidenced by the folks who pay 'em.

I think the lesson to be learned here is to make sure you get a refund policy set out, or ask for better scans. I asked for the scan of a Sky Bird back last night... it was a slabbed card, but PSA hadn't put enough card info on the slip, in my estimation.

I do think that just because a seller says 'no returns on graded cards' doesn't mean that is absolutely and totally enforceable, there could be situations where the seller's misidentified the card that would negate that.