Posted By:
runscottI would take Palmeiro on my team over McGwire any day. McGriff has also unquestionably been of great value to most clubs he played for, but I still dislike him for stretching so many doubles into singles while watching the beauty of his own swing. I'm a pro-hustle guy.
From what I remember about Kingman, he was considered to be fun in the clubhouse - really whacky prankster. Still, I put him in the same category as George Foster, just above guys like Pete Incaviglia and Steve Balboni, and way below Dale Murphy and Albert Belle...and I don't consider "likability" a qualification, though that's why Puckett made it and Belle may not.