[Archive]

Posted By: Eric Brehm

Here then is the list of the most recent prices realized for common-back T206's in PSA 2. The preference order for the top-tier Hall of Famers seems to be roughly Cobb - Young - Johnson - Mathewson - Speaker. And compared with the PSA 1 ranking, Elberfeld (Washington) has moved a ways up the list. Also note that the Magie error card is missing from this list; that would be because no PSA 2 example of that card sold during the time VCP has been collecting this data (for about the last three years I believe), at any of the venues that VCP tracks. However VCP does report several SGC 30 examples of the Magie card that sold during that period; the last one went for $13,145 in May 2008.

1.Wagner (Honus) $294,338.00
2.Plank $25,064.40
3.Demmitt (St. Louis) $3,200.00
4.O'Hara (St. Louis) $3,000.00
5.Sweeney (Bill) No B $1,171.20
6.Cobb (Portrait, Green Background) $960.00
7.Cobb (Bat On Shoulder) $660.00
8.Cobb (Bat Off Shoulder) $618.00
9.Cobb (Portrait, Red Background) $611.00
10.Young (Cy)(Cleveland, Glove Shows) $406.88
11.Elberfeld (Washington, Portrait) $404.00
12.Young (Cy)(Cleveland, Portrait) $367.12
13.Johnson (Portrait) $351.23
14.Mathewson (Portrait) $341.00
15.Young (Cy)(Cleveland, Bare Hand Shows) $317.00
16.Johnson (Pitching) $300.44
17.Mathewson (Dark Cap) $293.00
18.Mathewson (White Cap) $249.99
19.Brown (George)(Washington) $210.00
20.Devlin $199.99
21.Speaker $195.00
22.Dahlen (Brooklyn) $185.50
23.Evers (Portrait) $180.50
24.Lundgren (Chicago) $173.50
25.Lajoie (Portrait) $162.50
26.Smith (Frank, Chicago & Boston) $150.00
27.Tinker (Portrait) $150.00
28.Joss (Portrait) $135.00
29.Wheat $130.00
30.Brown (Mordecai)(Cubs On Shirt) $127.51
31.McGraw (Portrait, No Cap) $125.00
32.Lajoie (Throwing) $122.50
33.Evers (With Bat, Cubs On Shirt) $122.50
34.Lajoie (With Bat) $121.21
35.Jennings (Portrait) $117.50
36.Bernhard $114.50
37.Keeler (Portrait) $112.50
38.Lafitte $107.83
39.Tinker (Bat Off Shoulder) $106.09
40.Bender (Portrait) $102.50
41.Shaughnessy $102.50
42.Chance (Batting) $100.00
43.Doyle (Joe)(N.Y. Hands Above Head) $100.00
44.Brown (Mordecai)(Chicago On Shirt) $96.00
45.Persons $95.00
46.Collins (Philadelphia) $94.22
47.Tinker (Hands On Knees) $92.00
48.Keeler (Batting) $92.00
49.Paige $91.00
50.Brown (Mordecai)(Portrait) $90.11
51.Meyers $89.95
52.Powers $89.06
53.Flick $87.99
54.Waddell (Throwing) $87.78
55.Baker $85.78
56.Chesbro $84.77
57.King $83.00
58.Stark $83.00
59.Tinker (Bat On Shoulder) $82.00
60.Manion $80.99
61.Collins (Minneapolis) $80.23
62.Hooker $78.00
63.Willis (With Bat) $78.00
64.Bastian $78.00
65.Revelle $77.00
66.Gandil $76.99
67.Crawford (With Bat) $76.89
68.Cranston $76.88
69.Chance (Portrait, Red Background) $76.88
70.Carey $76.88
71.Clarke (Fred)(Portrait) $76.75
72.Violat (Viola) $76.00
73.Otey $74.99
74.Lipe $73.66
75.Joss (Pitching) $72.50
76.McGraw (Finger In Air) $72.50
77.Davis (G.) $72.00
78.Evers (With Bat, Chicago On Shirt) $71.56
79.Marquard (Pitching Follow-Through) $71.00
80.Bresnahan (With Bat) $69.95
81.McGraw (Portrait, With Cap) $69.00
82.Helm $67.00
83.Jennings (Both Hands Showing) $66.00
84.Walsh $66.00
85.Smith (Carlos, Shreveport) $65.00
86.Seitz $63.00
87.Hickman $62.88
88.Westlake $62.00
89.Rockenfeld $61.99
90.Bender (Pitching, Trees In Background) $61.88
91.Mullaney $61.00
92.Beckley $60.83
93.McGinnity $60.00
94.Carrigan $59.95
95.Crawford (Throwing) $59.89
96.Orth $59.77
97.Willis (Throwing) $59.76
98.Molesworth $59.15
99.Waddell (Portrait) $58.00
100.Duffy $57.99
101.Marquard (Hands At Thighs) $57.64
102.Howell (Hand At Waist) $57.50
103.Chance (Portrait, Yellow Background) $57.21
104.Howard (Savannah) $56.99
105.Adkins $56.88
106.Fritz $56.00
107.Willis (Portrait) $56.00
108.Demmitt (New York) $56.00
109.McGraw (Glove At Hip) $54.89
110.Bay $54.88
111.Hart (Jim, Montgomery) $54.67
112.Wilhelm (With Bat) $53.10
113.Schulte (Front View) $52.75
114.Chase (Portrait, Blue Background) $52.50
115.Sheckard (Glove Showing) $52.00
116.Brown (George)(Chicago) $52.00
117.Marquard (Portrait) $52.00
118.Jordan (A.O., Atlanta) $52.00
119.Reagan $52.00
120.Ganzel $51.99
121.Magee (Portrait) $51.01
122.Cree $51.00
123.Breitenstein $51.00
124.Beaumont $50.00
125.Slagle $50.00
126.Chase (Throwing, Dark Cap) $50.00
127.Bender (Pitching, No Trees In Background) $49.99
128.Griffith (Batting) $49.95
129.Hofman (Solly) $49.95
130.Kleinow (New York, Catching) $49.18
131.Thomas $49.09
132.Foster $49.04
133.Griffith (Portrait) $48.77
134.Lentz (Sentz) $48.55
135.Cicotte $48.55
136.Thornton $48.00
137.Smith (Sid, Atlanta) $48.00
138.Taylor $47.99
139.Greminger $47.04
140.Kleinow (Boston) $47.00
141.Ryan $47.00
142.Kiernan $47.00
143.Kelley $46.78
144.McCauley $46.00
145.Ellam $45.04
146.Shannon $45.00
147.Chase (Portrait, Pink Background) $44.88
148.Huggins (Hands At Mouth) $44.85
149.Huggins (Portrait) $44.11
150.McElveen $43.50
151.Merkle (Portrait) $43.12
152.Delehanty (Jim) $43.00
153.Pelty (Vertical Photo) $43.00
154.Miller (Dallas) $43.00
155.Bresnahan (Portrait) $43.00
156.Chase (Throwing, White Cap) $43.00
157.Jackson $43.00
158.Hoffman (IZZY-Prov) $42.26
159.Dooin $42.01
160.Birmingham $42.00
161.Hart (Bill, Little Rock) $42.00
162.Wallace $42.00
163.Needham $42.00
164.Reulbach (Glove Showing) $42.00
165.Thebo $42.00
166.Kling $41.77
167.Jennings (One Hand Showing) $41.02
168.Reulbach (No Glove Showing) $41.00
169.Schulte (Back View) $41.00
170.Lundgren (Kansas City) $41.00
171.Steinfeldt (With Bat) $40.44
172.Clarke (Fred)(Holding Bat) $40.00
173.Abstein $40.00
174.Dunn (Jack, Baltimore) $39.99
175.Guiheen $39.77
176.Merkle (Throwing) $39.00
177.Ritter $38.50
178.Overall (Hands Waist Level) $37.99
179.Pfeister (Pfiester, Seated) $37.85
180.Ames (Hands At Chest) $37.77
181.Lake (St. Louis, No Ball In Hand) $37.75
182.Howard (Chicago) $37.01
183.Barry (Shad) $37.00
184.Mattern $37.00
185.Bell (Pitching Follow Through) $37.00
186.Perdue $37.00
187.Knight (Portrait) $36.67
188.Crandall (Portrait, With Cap) $36.67
189.Durham $36.11
190.Pfeffer $36.00
191.Lord $36.00
192.Scott $36.00
193.O'Hara (New York) $35.77
194.Evans $35.67
195.Leach (Portrait) $35.51
196.Quinn $35.33
197.Abbaticchio (Brown Sleeves) $35.01
198.Powell $35.01
199.Niles $35.00
200.Delehanty (Frank) $35.00
201.Konetchy (Glove Near Ground) $35.00
202.Frill $35.00
203.Purtell $35.00
204.Phelan $35.00
205.White (Doc, Chicago, Pitching) $34.99
206.Overall (Portrait) $34.95
207.Tenney $34.95
208.McIntyre (Brooklyn & Chicago) $34.67
209.Doolan (Fielding) $34.33
210.Phillippe $34.00
211.White (Foley, Houston) $33.88
212.Manning (Batting) $33.63
213.Abbaticchio (Blue Sleeves) $33.57
214.Steinfeldt (Portrait) $33.55
215.Wilhelm (Hands At Chest) $33.50
216.Sullivan $33.22
217.Tannehill (Lee)(Chicago, L. Tannehill On Front) $33.05
218.Wagner (Heinie)(Bat On Right Shoulder) $33.05
219.Leach (Bending Over) $33.00
220.Stovall (Portrait) $33.00
221.Herzog (Boston) $33.00
222.Snodgrass (Catching) $33.00
223.Camnitz (Arm At Side) $32.67
224.Doyle (Larry)(With Bat) $32.55
225.Leifield (Pitching) $32.50
226.Brashear $32.45
227.Donlin (Fielding) $32.33
228.McQuillan (Ball In Hand) $32.00
229.Shaw (Hunky, Providence) $32.00
230.Ewing $32.00
231.Donovan (Portrait) $32.00
232.Hall $31.99
233.Ames (Portrait) $31.55
234.Lake (New York) $31.50
235.Fiene (Portrait) $31.05
236.Bell (Hands Above Head) $31.01
237.Warhop $31.00
238.Marshall $31.00
239.Graham (St. Louis) $31.00
240.Blackburne $31.00
241.Randall $31.00
242.Conroy (With Bat) $31.00
243.Easterly $30.98
244.Lobert $30.76
245.Mowrey $30.67
246.Smith (Frank, Chicago, White Cap) $30.63
247.Zimmerman $30.50
248.Owen $30.00
249.Moran (Pat, Chicago) $30.00
250.Egan $30.00
251.McBride $30.00
252.Liebhardt $29.99
253.Hoffman (Danny-S.L.) $29.99
254.Kleinow (New York, With Bat) $29.95
255.Quillen (Quillin) $29.88
256.Schaefer (Detroit) $29.65
257.Magee (With Bat) $29.55
258.Cassidy $29.00
259.Coles $28.99
260.Mitchell (Mike, Cincinnati) $28.88
261.Doolin $28.81
262.Pattee $28.77
263.Donlin (With Bat) $28.77
264.Crandall (Portrait, No Cap) $28.67
265.Bates $28.55
266.Doyle (Larry)(Throwing) $28.51
267.Wilson $28.50
268.Jordan (Brookyn, Portrait) $28.05
269.Brain $28.00
270.Wagner (Heinie)(Bat On Left Shoulder) $28.00
271.Ball (New York) $28.00
272.Milan $28.00
273.Gibson $28.00
274.Criger $27.99
275.Barbeau $27.99
276.Wiltse (Portrait, With Cap) $27.95
277.Lavender $27.80
278.Bush $27.77
279.Wiltse (Portrait, No Cap) $27.77
280.White (Doc, Chicago, Portrait) $27.50
281.Bridwell (Portrait, No Cap) $27.33
282.Ferguson $27.20
283.McIntyre (Detroit) $27.05
284.McGann $27.02
285.Murphy (Batting) $27.01
286.Elberfeld (New York) $27.00
287.Clark (Josh) $27.00
288.Burch (Fielding) $27.00
289.Williams $27.00
290.Ganley $27.00
291.Myers (Batting) $27.00
292.Atz $26.99
293.Knight (With Bat) $26.99
294.Armbruster $26.89
295.McGlynn $26.88
296.Thielman $26.80
297.Clarke (J.J.) $26.77
298.Spade $26.77
299.Shaw (Al, St. Louis) $26.66
300.Doolan (Batting) $26.59
301.Seymour (Batting) $26.27
302.Dessau $26.20
303.Street (Catching) $26.01
304.Turner $26.01
305.Bescher (Hands In Air) $26.01
306.Herzog (New York) $26.01
307.Davis (Phila. H. Davis On Front) $26.01
308.Hinchman (Cleveland)Bill $26.00
309.Bliss $26.00
310.Chase (Holding Trophy) $26.00
311.O'Leary (Hands On Knees) $26.00
312.Hartsel $26.00
313.Camnitz (Arms Folded) $26.00
314.Davidson $26.00
315.Carr $26.00
316.McLean $26.00
317.Dougherty (Portrait) $26.00
318.Anderson $26.00
319.Gray $26.00
320.Downey (Fielding) $26.00
321.Bowerman $26.00
322.McCormick $26.00
323.Payne $26.00
324.Charles $26.00
325.Murray (Batting) $26.00
326.Hemphill $26.00
327.Nicholls (Hands On Knees) $26.00
328.Maddox $25.99
329.Dubuc $25.49
330.Hayden $25.49
331.Burch (Batting) $25.36
332.Ford $25.21
333.Seymour (Portrait) $25.05
334.Howell (Portrait) $25.01
335.White (Jack, Buffalo) $25.00
336.Schreck $25.00
337.Ames (Hands Above Head) $25.00
338.Ritchey $25.00
339.Clancy (Clancey) $24.99
340.Donahue (Donohue) $24.95
341.Schlafly $24.95
342.Cravath $24.95
343.Hahn $24.95
344.Nattress $24.95
345.Milligan $24.75
346.Spencer $24.59
347.Sheckard (No Glove Showing) $24.51
348.Stahl (Glove Shows) $24.50
349.Kroh $24.50
350.Chappelle $24.50
351.Barger $24.50
352.Wiltse (Pitching) $24.50
353.Hummel $24.50
354.Bransfield $24.50
355.Rucker (Throwing) $24.49
356.Mullin (With Bat) $24.49
357.Strang $24.00
358.Weimer $24.00
359.Byrne $23.85
360.Shipke $23.65
361.Mitchell (Fred, Toronto) $23.51
362.Congalton $23.51
363.Unglaub $23.50
364.Young (Irv)(Minneapolis) $23.50
365.Pastorius $23.50
366.Smith (Frank, Chicago, F. Smith On Front) $23.50
367.Oldring (Batting) $23.50
368.Stone $23.50
369.Bergen (Batting) $23.50
370.McIntyre (Brooklyn) $23.50
371.Willett (Bat on shoulder) $23.49
372.Kruger (Krueger) $23.46
373.Rucker (Portrait) $23.42
374.Stanage $23.39
375.Downs $23.26
376.O'Neil $23.10
377.Conroy (Fielding) $23.06
378.Latham $23.04
379.Snodgrass (Batting) $23.03
380.Murphy (Throwing) $23.00
381.Gilbert $23.00
382.Karger $23.00
383.Beck $23.00
384.Burns $23.00
385.Seymour (Throwing) $23.00
386.Konetchy (Glove Above Head) $22.94
387.Engle $22.83
388.Kisinger $22.83
389.Sweeney (Bill)(Boston) $22.80
390.Sweeney (Jeff)(New York) $22.72
391.Leifield (Batting) $22.72
392.Elberfeld (Washington, Fielding) $22.56
393.Doyle (Larry)(Portrait) $22.55
394.Krause (Pitching) $22.51
395.Hoblitzell $22.50
396.Puttman (Puttmann) $22.50
397.Gaspar $22.50
398.Casey $22.50
399.Poland $22.50
400.Stovall (Batting) $22.50
401.Raymond $22.38
402.Geyer $22.27
403.Tannehill (Lee)(Chicago, Tannehill On Front) $22.16
404.Merritt $22.05
405.McQuillan (With Bat) $22.01
406.Becker $22.00
407.Bradley (Portrait) $22.00
408.Batch $22.00
409.Schirm $22.00
410.Rossman $21.94
411.Clymer $21.94
412.Ferris $21.90
413.Schlei (Batting) $21.72
414.Nichols (Nicholls, Batting) $21.71
415.Schlei (Catching) $21.55
416.Killian (Portrait) $21.51
417.Hulswitt $21.51
418.Lattimore $21.50
419.Parent $21.50
420.Moeller $21.50
421.Bescher (Portrait) $21.50
422.Hunter $21.50
423.Camnitz (Hands Above Head) $21.50
424.Abbott $21.49
425.Miller (Pittsburgh) $21.38
426.Summers $21.27
427.Donlin (Seated) $21.01
428.Isbell $21.01
429.Downey (Batting) $21.00
430.Schmidt (Throwing) $21.00
431.Smith (Happy, Brooklyn) $20.71
432.Malarkey $20.69
433.Willetts (Throwing) $20.59
434.Fiene (Throwing) $20.52
435.Stahl (No Glove Shows) $20.52
436.McAleese $20.51
437.Arndt $20.51
438.Groom $20.51
439.Murray (Portrait) $20.51
440.Hallman $20.51
441.Phelps $20.51
442.Moriarty $20.51
443.Hannifan (Hannifin) $20.51
444.Schmidt (Portrait) $20.50
445.Burke $20.50
446.Ball (Cleveland) $20.50
447.Dahlen (Boston) $20.50
448.Covaleski (Coveleski) $20.50
449.Dougherty (Arm In Air) $20.49
450.Stephens $20.49
451.Perring $20.49
452.Bergen (Catching) $20.49
453.Dunn (Joe, Brooklyn) $20.49
454.Bridwell (Portrait, With Cap) $20.49
455.Myers (Fielding) $20.49
456.Pfeister (Pfiester, Throwing) $20.49
457.Schaefer (Washington) $20.49
458.Butler $20.49
459.Lumley $20.49
460.Goode (Good) $20.49
461.Jones (F., Hands At Hips) $20.46
462.Freeman $20.27
463.Mullen (Mullin) $20.02
464.Oldring (Fielding) $20.00
465.Manning (Pitching) $20.00
466.Livingstone (Livingston) $20.00
467.Maloney $20.00
468.Cross $20.00
469.Oakes $19.99
470.Mullin (Horizontal) $19.99
471.Hinchman (Toledo) $19.99
472.Pelty (Horizontal Photo) $19.99
473.Krause (Portrait) $19.95
474.Sharpe $19.94
475.Lake (St. Louis, Ball In Hand) $19.75
476.Oberlin $19.27
477.Jacklitsch $19.03
478.Rudolph $18.84
479.Rhoades (Hands At Chest) $18.50
480.Starr $18.50
481.Killian (Pitching) $18.50
482.Paskert $18.50
483.Titus $18.49
484.Grimshaw $18.49
485.Criss $18.01
486.Barry (Jack) $18.00
487.Jones (F., Portrait) $17.71
488.Street (Portrait) $17.51
489.O'Leary (Portrait) $17.50
490.Moran (Herb, Providence) $17.50
491.Wright $17.50
492.Flanagan $17.49
493.Bradley (With Bat) $17.00
494.Arellanes $16.79
495.Fletcher $16.50
496.O'Brien $16.50
497.Lennox $16.50
498.Jones (Tom, St. Louis) $16.50
499.Dygert $16.50
500.Dorner $16.50
501.Knabe $16.31
502.Davis (Phila. Davis On Front) $16.03
503.Tannehill (Jesse)(Washington) $16.02
504.Alperman $16.01
505.Jordan (Brookyn, Batting) $16.01
506.Rhoades (Right Arm Extended) $16.00
507.Jones (Davy, Detroit) $16.00
508.LaPorte $16.00
509.Campbell $15.51
510.McGinley $15.50
511.Fromme $15.50
512.Berger $15.50
513.Graham-Peaches(Boston) $15.04
514.Rhodes $12.16