I think it is a great idea, although the logistics may be an issue.
- If there is a sticky thread of 'Good' and/or 'Bad', would it be user friendly enough to be effective?
- Can the "is it good" thread photo easily be added to the "Exemplar" thread?
For example, I think that Mark's (?) boxing exemplars replies are outstanding in that it show's the bad along with several (dozen sometimes
) good.
One option would to be to create a sub-forum and have threads on good and bad for particular players. Posts would be updated as consensus is reached, but any discussion would be kept separate from the "exemplar" threads.
That being said, a project like this seems difficult on a chat forum. It may well be better suited to a web page format.