Posted By:
Griffin'sI've cracked about 50 Cracker Jacks out of SGC holders and put them into PSA's (about half stayed the same grade, the other half bumped up). When I had mixed stacks I just shot them across the room, so it was easier to have a uniform holder stack. I'm sure in the end it all evens up.
The pop reports on both SGC and PSA are out of whack, but at least it's a guideline. I talked to one dealer who cracks and submits up to 12 times on a given card until he gets the grade he thinks it deserves. The pops are never adjusted. The only one that would seem accurate is PSA's T3 pops, but with SGC grading them soon I'm sure it will be off as well.