I think the Joss has a chance of being ok. A very slightly curved cut can happen, it's unusual but possible. The bottom edge looks ok, no odd transitions from worn to not worn, and the overall quality of the edge looks the same all the way across. The top edge doesn't look as good, a bit more sharp, and there are a couple quirky things to the curve.
It will be interesting to see how it gets graded.
Steve B
|