Quote:
Originally Posted by benjulmag
Given all the credible questions raised about the PSA 8 Wagner and that it remains PSA's signature item, IMO the proper thing to do is to re-grade it according PSA's current standards. If if fact it does not exhibit such signs suggesting it was after-the-fact cut from a sheet (and then subsequently possibly trimmed), it can be re-slabbed with an appropriate numerical grade. If though it exhibits such characteristics that would cause PSA to grade as an "A" another currently submitted card with identical characteristics, then it should be given an "A". This approach makes moot what did or did not happen in the past and evaluates the card based on factual criteria.
Oh, and right, like I really think this is going to happen.  |
All PSA has to do is leave it in the 8 holder and put a (Handcut) qualifier on the flip. That satisfies everyone (including me, not that it matters)....and the value probably goes up again!!
