[bmarlowe1]

smokelessjoe -

quoting a disinguished board member from a prior thread:
"There's a RESEMBLANCE. But without more, it should die there. Resemblances alone almost always lead to nowhere."

The reason we are being "negative" is in an effort to counter the large lack of critical thinking that causes people to bid big $ on photos like this.

First of all you are comparing a fuzzy image to another fuzzy image - pretty worthless. BTW - if you compare the nose to a clear Chadwick semi-profile image - it doesn't seem quite right. But again - the tintype is too fuzzy to be sure about anything.