Posted By:
Richard MassonI would be inclined to believe the Wagner throwing pose may be one of the scarce cards in the set. I looked for an upgrade (to a modest VG) for several years before finding one. It may not be obvious because the pose is repeated on other caramel cards (Dockman, Nadja, Crofts, E106, etc., etc....).
My further two cents is that the pop reports are not meaningful to determine scarcity. There are not many registry collectors of the set, and I crossed two full sets (Caramel Monster and Caramel's Little Brother) from PSA to SGC last year, so I know there is at least some double counting. There are also many raw sets still floating around out there. This set is part of any decent "old school" collection.