[Archive]

Posted By: chris bland

If minor league cards are not considered rookie cards, then the Buck Weaver Obak card should not be listed as his rookie.

I personally disagree with a lot of the "rookie" designations in the auction (For example, a 1928 Carl Hubbell R315 was auctioned by Barry on ebay as a rookie but in this auction a 1933 Sport Kings Hubbell is labeled as a rookie as well) but, but this is a topic where a ton of different opinions exist, and I don't know if any one opinion is right or wrong...