Posted By:
Brian H (misunderestimated)Easily rates in the top 10 2nd Basemen of all time simply in terms of his playing (bracketing out the fact that he was likely the most significant player in the history of the major leagues).
The knock on him (purely as a player) is that his career was realively short and therefore his career numbers don't compare well with the other top 2Bs. However, during his career he was incredibly valuable (like his teammate Campanella) to a great team. He was also a complete player and winner. That has to be balanced against other 2Bs with lots of lifetime hits (e.g. Biggio) who were never really in the hunt for the MVP and never led their teams to championships. BTW. I would put Biggio (and Alomar, too) in the HOF so I'm just saying that he falls beneath Robinson in my ratings.
Guys like COllins, Lajoie, Hornsby and Morgan have both Biggio's long term stature and Robinson's "peak value" so I would have to put them above Robinson.