Posted By:
Joe D.my comment (as titled) was from a customer's perspective. Not so much from a legal perspective (which I defer to people more learned than I am).
But as a prospective customer....
I find it troubling that this is the current return policy and yet it is not being abided by.
As a customer, am I to believe that the auction house will abide by a reputable grading company's opinion for all future items.... or will there always be the "well they could be wrong or mistaken" defense?
And as noted by Leon.... a buyer is there if the item is legit. I could only scratch my head and wonder why an auction house would balk at a return that is very much consistent with their current philosophy as to what a 'good reason' for a return would be.... especially if they believe the item to be genuine and could sell it to someone else.
edit: grammar (probably still wrong)