Posted By:
cmokingBrian - Cameron Jack is doing great. Did you receive and read my book yet?
The 1957 Topps Mantle PSA 10 is the only one graded PSA 10. The people bidding on that card are bidding on condition scarcity. Many here will think those people are crazy, but it shouldn't be a surprise as we've all seen it many times in the past. The price has little to do with the number of 57 Mantles or the overall trend in 50s prices. It has to do with a pop of one....just my opinion of course.
I also think that catalog auctions from well-known houses get higher prices than ebay prices in general, as they can get in touch with bidders who may not follow ebay closely.
I've been following the 34 Goudeys closely on Memory Lane - I wouldn't say those prices are surprising at all...seems right in line for a catalog auction.