Posted By:
PCThe seller may not know what he's selling.
I once sent an email to PSA alerting them to an obviously fake "PSA"-slabbed card on ebay: it was a PSA flip inserted in an oversized screwdown holder (couldn't tell if the flip was real or not, but the slab was clearly homemade). I received a short, to the point, email thanking me and letting me know that "they are on it" ... the auction was taken down in less than an hour.
Not sure how PSA would respond to this auction. Having an auction pulled with a third-party faked slab is one thing, but if PSA did slab the fake Gehrig then they might not be so quick to take ownership of the problem.