[Archive]

Posted By: ramram

He played sparingly in 1884, 85, 86 & 87 in the majors. Since he only played 18 games for Philly that year he very well could have been playing with Oshkosh.

BTW, I never looked closely at McCarthy's career stats. As I got looking at his career numbers it made me wonder...who were the drinkers on the 1946 HOF comittee? McCarthy's numbers aren't even remotely close to HOF numbers. It wasn't his managing either. Was he an executive?