Posted By:
WesleyThere is a world of difference between the E107 Young and the E102 Cobb. First did you see the scan of the Young card? There are only a few of those cards in any condition, and in such nice condition, the card is virtually impossible to replace.
That is not the case with the E102 Cobb in Fair condition. Your card is very nice, but you can easily replace it with another Fair condition E102 Cobb for no more than $850.
I respect your attitude about cards vs. money but still do not completely understand. Surely, if someone traded you a nearly identical E102 Cobb in Fair condition, in addition to handing you a check for $1650, you would have no objection. If the offer is genuine, that is essentially what that dealer is doing. If you sell the Cobb you will have no problem replacing it with a similar or superior copy in the next three months.