Posted By:
petecldI agree, the Tinker and Speaker are trimmed.
I'll assume the Evers grade is due to the pinhole.
More fine examples of PSA's complete lack of ability to grade vintage cards. This is surprising thugh, I thought they only graded trimmed e-cards. Just my opinion.
Seriously, I'm not so sure the grade on the Evers is all that out of line. To me, it's a nice VG card w/o the pinhole and assuming there are no creases we can't see. In a case like this are they are da**ed either way? If they give it a "3" people will ask, "Why is it graded that high with a pin hole?" With a "1" we are asking, "Why so low, is it the pinhole?"
What does everyone think a fair grade would be for th Evers? In my eyes a pin hole has a MUCH greater impact on grade then a crease.