[Seven]

Originally Posted by jsfriedm

Not sure how people want to consider this, but Mantle was a much better right-handed hitter than lefty - he hit .330 for his career righty. So can we include right-handed Mantle on the list?

Mantle also was never the same from the left handed side of the plate after Red Schoendist landed on his right shoulder in the World Series.

As for the question, I'd probably say Hornsby or Foxx. I think depending on how the rest of his career shapes up, however, we might be able to say Mike Trout.