Quote:
Originally Posted by rainier2004
So would the deal have been acceptable if Tim hadn't said "it should grade a 3"?
|
I'd be inclined to say yes.
The seller indicated that he is not a professional and offers no guarantee. That is perfectly fine, but then I wouldn't make a prediction as to what the card would possibly grade. I would suggest posting clear, accurate scans and allow potential buyers to make their own determination.
Perhaps it is a question of degrees. To me, I believe that card would grade a 1.5. That is enough standard deviations away from a 3 where I think a potential recipient would be unhappy with the transaction.
I'd also agree that the seller had little time to respond before drastic action was taken by the creation of this thread.