Quote:
Originally Posted by Topps206
I agree with all you say. Sheckard isn't an injustice if an omission, but I could live with his induction.
Magee? He stands the test of time. How is he not in yet? Why do we have to wait until 2020, at least?
How Magee and Bad Bill are not in when both are easily qualified is puzzling to me.
Edit: Look how long it took to induct George Davis, arguably a top five shortstop of all time! The voters don't always get it right.
|
Magee I don't understand. He is the same as Wheat and Kelley. He should be in already.
Dahlen wasn't the defensive player that Wallace or Tinker were. Not being outstanding, just very good, both offensively and defensively doesn't necessarily mean you are a hofer. Davis was outstanding defensively. Why he didn't make it earlier makes no sense to me.