Based on the line-ups and final score, this game between the Boston Beaneaters and New York Giants was played on September 1st, 1888.
The Giants beat Boston 5 - 2 on their way to becoming the World Champions that year.
Line-ups include 7 Hall of Famers, 5 for NY and 2 for Boston (same as the final score!)
Boston HOFers: Mike "King" Kelly and John Clarkson
NY HOFers: Buck Ewing, Roger Conner, John Montgomery Ward, Jim O'Rourke and Mickey Welch