Isn't PSA more strict on centering and a bit more lenient on light creases even in groups?
That might explain it.
Personally I'd have given them both 2s, I always understood a creased card as no better than G unless the rest was amazing.
I've sort of benefitted from SGC giving one card of mine that I thought should be a 30 a 40 so I can't complain too much. (Sort of since it's an expensive card I'm not selling so no real benefit yet)
Steve B
|