This Wagner is No. 13 on
T206Resource.com's sales-history list, which shows that it last sold publicly in 2005.
http://t206resource.com/WagnerSales.html
http://www.legendaryauctions.com/Lot...entoryid=45387
Given that PSA didn't have half-grades then, I can see how, if having to choose between grading this card a 1 or a 2, PSA went with a 2. The card is closer to being good than it is poor. But yeah, I'd grade it fair.