[Shoeless Moe]

.....with Ctownboy, I do not think you can flat out say "No".

1 most attempts at fraud are done using the bigger name players.

2 While yes anyone can make up a story, and it's possible this one is made up too. I'd personally see if the seller could provide more evidence to back up their story.

Are the glove and card vintage as well? Or modern day....modern day, sellers full of it....vintage, then still possibly real.

Granted no way of ever knowing 100% on many items we come accross, but I like the civil court where it doesn't have to be beyond a reasonable doubt, but rather the preponderance of the evidence.

I'd see if they can dig up anything else on dear old grandpa was in fact deaf. Also, look at every one of the sellers past transactions, not that that proves anything, but you never know what you may or may not uncover.

Don't give up until the ship is lost!