I would agree with Mike on this one.... value is definitely under $100, unless there is a desirable HOF Player endorsement that you haven't disclosed.
If it had a "sewn" web in this condition, it would be more desirable/valuable, and probably worth $150 - $200. This type is just a lot more common. Still a nice display piece.
I think a $75 price for your neighbor sounds like a win-win. You get a good price + easy sale. He gets a nice display glove with no shipping charge or buyer's premium.
