Net54baseball.com Forums

Net54baseball.com Forums (http://www.net54baseball.com/index.php)
-   Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions (http://www.net54baseball.com/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   T206 EPDG Back Question (http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=92370)

Archive 02-16-2009 11:35 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>RayB</b><p>T206 EPDG Back Question<br>February 16 2009 at 2:33 PM RayB <br>--------------------------------------------------------------------------------<br>In reviewing Scot Readers fine text &quot;Inside T-206&quot; he charts (under Series Discussion Page 23) all the possible Back designations for the different Series of T206 cards. <br><br><br><br>Following the logic established in this chart it would follow that there could be theoretically 477 different cards with a T206 Back. <br><br><br><br>If you exclude the &quot;Rule Breakers&quot; (7 cards) completely then the final tally would be 470 theoretical possibilities. <br><br><br><br>In previous discussions on this topic about the EPDG Back there was an argument offered for a lesser number but in rereading the entire Reader text again twice I couldn't follow how that could or would be the case. <br><br><br><br>I can say for sure, with the help of previous work done by our own Ted Z., that I have substantiated the existance of only 276 different examples to date. <br><br><br><br>Can anyone add to substantiate or refute the theoretical total of EPDG's and bring this discussion back to date? <br><br>Insight from our resident T206 guru's is, of course, appreciated. <br><br><br><br>RayB <br><br><a href="http://i86.photobucket.com/albums/k94/aja4rayb/livingstoneRaw" rel="nofollow"></a>

Archive 02-16-2009 08:05 PM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Scot Reader</b><p><br>Ray,<br><br>You can remove the 12 150-only subjects from the ranks of the theoretically possible with EPDG, if you haven't already.<br><br>I'm referring to:<br><br>Ames (Hands at Chest)<br>G. Brown (Chicago)<br>M. Brown (Cubs on Shirt)<br>Burch (Batting)<br>Donlin (Fielding)<br>Doyle (Throwing)<br>Evers (Blue Sky)<br>Pattee<br>Pelty (Horizontal)<br>Powers<br>Reulbach (Glove Shows)<br>Schulte (Front View)<br><br>I am now convinced that those don't exist, my 2006 checklist notwithstanding.<br><br>Ted's EPDG survey will give you a good idea about which subjects are actually possible with EPDG, although all subjects from the 150/350, 350-only, 350/460 SP, 350/460 RP and 460-only subject groups are theoretically possible with that back.<br><br>Scot<br><br>

Archive 02-16-2009 08:46 PM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Dan Koochin</b><p>Can't say I've ever seen a green portrait Cobb EPDG, a no print as well.<br><br>are you debating whether you 'should' see all 470 or so on EPDG based on<br>the small sample size from the previous surveys on the board? or do feel<br>you're close at to the EPDG 'set' at 270-something?<br><br>but isn't that dependent on how you 'see' the timeline of issue?<br>I see it as a fall 1910 350 series issue, but feel the Piedmont set<br>is more complete (possibly because Piedmont issued a short run 150/350<br>series prior to EPDG) ....would be interesting to see if Ritchey <br>dove and no-dove both appear in EPDG or not.....<br><br>

Archive 02-17-2009 05:33 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>RayB</b><p>Dan - Yes. The 276 count is an ongoing effort to continue to update the oroginal List that Ted Z compiled partly as a result of input here on the Boards.<br>I continue to watch for additional examples.<br>RayB

Archive 02-17-2009 09:48 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Ted Zanidakis</b><p>Updated list of confirmed El Principe de Gales cards (280)......Feb 17, 2009<br><br><br>Abbaticchio (brown sleeves)<br>Abbaticchio (blue sleeves)<br>Abbott<br>Adkins<br>Ames (hands/head)<br>Anderson<br>Atz<br>Baker<br>Ball (New York)<br>Ball (Cleveland)<br>Barbeau<br>Barger<br>Batch<br>Bates <br>Beaumont<br>Beck<br>Bell (hands/head)<br>Bender (portrait)<br>Bender (trees)<br>Bergen (bat)<br>Bergen (catching)<br>Berger<br>Bescher (fielding)<br>Blackburne<br>Bliss<br>Bowerman<br>B radley (portrait)<br>Bradley (bat)<br>Brain<br>Brashear<br>Bresnahan (bat)<br>Bresnahan (portrait)<br>Bridwell (cap)<br>Bridwell (no cap)<br>M. Brown (Chicago)<br>Burch (fielding)<br>Burchell<br>Burke<br>Burns<br>Bush<b r>Camnitz (arms fold)<br>Camnitz (arms side)<br>Campbell<br>Casey<br>Chance (red portrait)<br>Chance (yellow portrait)<br>Chance (bat)<br>Chase (blue portrait)<br>Chase (pink portrait)<br>Chase (white cap)<br>Chase (dark cap)<br>Chesbro<br>Cicotte<br>Clarke (bat)<br>Clarke (portrait)<br>JJ Clarke<br>Cobb (red portrait)<br>Cobb (bat off)<br>Collins (A's)<br>Collins (Minneapolis)<br>Congalton<br>Conroy (bat)<br>Coveleski<br>Crandall (no cap)<br>Crandall (w/cap)<br>Cravath<br>Crawford (bat)<br>Cree<br>Criger<br>Dahlen (Boston)<br>Davidson<br>Geo Davis (Chicago)<br>Delehanty (Washington)<br>Demmitt (New York)<br>Devore<br>Donlin (bat)<br>Donlin (sitting)<br>Donovan (portrait)<br>Dooin<br>Doolan (bat)<br>Doolan (fielding)<br>Doolin<br>Dougherty (arms/air)<br>Downey (bat)<br>Joe Doyle<br>Larry Doyle (bat)<br>Larry Doyle (portrait)<br>Dubuc<br>Duffy<br>Dunn (Brooklyn)<br>Durham<br>Easterly<br>Egan<br>Elberf eld (Wash-fldg)<br>Evans<br>Evers (Chicago)<br>Evers (portrait)<br>Ewing<br>Fiene (portrait)<br>Fiene (throwing)<br>Flanagan<br>Ford<br>Freeman<br>Frill <br>Fromme<br>Gandil<br>Ganley<br>Gasper<br>Geyer< br>Gibson<br>Gilbert<br>Graham (Boston)<br>Graham (St Louis)<br>Gray<br>Griffith (portrait)<br>Groom<br>Hallman<br>Hannifan<br>Hart sell<br>Hemphill<br>Herzog (Boston)<br>Herzog (New York)<br>Hinchman (Cleveland)<br>Hinchman (Toronto)<br>Hoblitzell<br>Hofman<br>Howard (Chicago)<br>Howell (hands/waist)<br>Hulswitt<br>Hummell<br>Jackson<br>Jennin gs (portrait)<br>Jennings (1 hand)<br>Jennings (2 hands)<br>Johnson (portrait)<br>Johnson (pitch)<br>Tom Jones (St Louis)<br>Jordan (portrait)<br>Jordan (bat)<br>Joss (pitching)<br>Karger<br>Keeler (portrait)<br>Kelley<br>Killian (pitching)<br>Kisinger<br>Kleinow (Boston)<br>Kling<br>Knight (bat)<br>Konetchy (glove lo)<br>Konetchy (glove hi)<br>Krause (portrait)<br>Kruger<br>Lajoie (throw)<br>Lajoie (bat)<br>Lake, St. Lou. (no ball)<br>Lake, St. Lou. (ball) <br>Lattimore<br>Lavender<br>Leach (portrait)<br>Leach (cap)<br>Leifield (pitching)<br>Leifeld (bat)<br>Lindaman<br>Livingstone<br>Lobert<br>Lord <br>Lumley<br>Lundgren (Cubs)<br>Lundgren (KC)<br>Maddox<br>Magee (portrait)<br>Magee (bat)<br>Marquard (hds/side)<br>Mathewson (wh cap)<br>Mathewson (dark cap)<br>Mattern<br>McAleese<br>McCormick<br>McGraw (portrait-w cap)<br>McIntyre (Brooklyn/Chicago)<br>McLean<br>McQuillan (ball/hand)<br>Merritt<br>Meyers (portrait)<br>Miller (Pittsburg)<br>Milligan<br>Mullin (bat)<br>Mullin (throw)<br>Murphy (bat)<br>Murray (portrait)<br>Myers (fielding)<br>Nattress<br>Needham<br>Nichols<br>Ni les<br>Oakes<br>Oberlin<br>O'Leary (portrait)<br>O'Leary (hds/knees)<br>Oldring (bat)<br>Overall (portrait)<br>Overall (yellow sky)<br>Owen<br>Payne<br>Pfeffer<br>Pfiester (seated)<br>Pfeister (throw)<br>Phillippe<br>Powell<br>Purtell<br>Puttm an<br>Quillen<br>Reulbach (no glove)<br>Raymond<br>Rhoades (hds/chest)<br>Rhoades (throwing)<br>Rhodes<br>Ritchey<br>Rucker (portrait)<br>Rudolph<br>Schaefer (Detroit)<br>Schlafly<br>Schlei (catching)<br>Schulte (back)<br>Scott<br>Seymour (bat<br>Schmidt (throwing)<br>Shannon<br>Sharpe<br>Shaw (St Louis)<br>Sheckard (glove)<br>Shipke<br>Smith (Brooklyn)<br>Smith (Buffalo)<br>F. Smith (Chicago)<br>Snodgrass (bat)<br>Snodgrass (catching)<br>Spade<br>Spencer<br>Stahl (glove)<br>Stanage<br>Steinfeldt (portrait)<br>Steinfeldt (bat)<br>Stephens<br>Stovall (portrait)<br>Stovall (bat)<br>Street (catching)<br>Sweeney (Boston)<br>Sweeney (New York)<br>L Tannehill<br>J Tannehill (Washington)<br>Taylor<br>Thomas<br>Tinker (portrait)<br>Tinker (bat off)<br>Tinker (bat on)<br>Titus<br>Turner<br>Wagner (bat/left)<br>Wagner (bat/right)<br>Walsh<br>Weimer<br>Wheat<br>White (Buffalo)<br>White (Chicago-port)<br>White (Chicago-pitching)<br>Wilhelm (arms/chest)<br>Wilhelm (bat)<br>Willett<br>Willetts<br>Willis (St Louis)<br>Willis (with bat)<br>Wilson<br>Wiltse (portrait-no cap)<br>Wiltse (pitching)<br>Wright<br>CYoung (portrait)<br>CYoung (bare hand)<br>CYoung (glove)<br>Zimmerman<br><br><br>TED Z<br><br>

Archive 02-17-2009 10:50 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>RayB</b><p>Ted,<br><br>Edited to say in cross checking my list against yours we are actually now up to 282 as my list confirms Mordecai Brown Throwing and Overall Blue Sky Pitching.<br>Thanks for filling me in on your additions.<br><br>282 Now.<br>RayB<br><br>RayB

Archive 02-17-2009 03:43 PM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>RayB</b><p>Bumped for edited response above about more checklist additions.<br>RayB<br><br>Count is 282.

Archive 02-17-2009 05:03 PM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Ted Zanidakis</b><p>I already have &quot;Mordecai Brown Throwing&quot; on the list as....M. Brown (Chicago).<br><br>Overall (blue sky) is a good one.<br><br>With the problem in editing (extraneous line spacing), I'll reprise the list to add Overall next time I post here.<br><br>Thanks,<br><br>TED Z<br><br>

Archive 02-17-2009 05:33 PM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>RayB</b><p>Ted,<br><br>There has also been a M. Brown Portait Confirmation<br><br>Ray<br><br>Still 282.

Archive 02-18-2009 07:01 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Ted Zanidakis</b><p>The maximum number of T206 Subjects that were possibly printed with EPDG backs......<br><br>524 = T206 total cards<br>--6 [Doyle error, Magie, Plank, Wagner, Demmitt &amp; O'Hara (St Lo vars.)]<br>-48 (So Lgrs)<br>-12 (150 only)<br>--2 [Dahlen (Brooklyn) &amp; Elberfeld (Washington-portrait)]<br>----<br>456 EPDG candidates<br><br><br><br>Approx. 4 years after our EPDG survey we now have 282 confirmed EPDG cards.<br><br>The remaining 174 unseen Subjects may just never been printed. There is a high probability, that after 4 years<br>of sampling, we may have accounted for 95 to 99% of the printed EPDG cards.<br><br><br><br>TED Z<br><br>

Archive 02-18-2009 07:04 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Ted Zanidakis</b><p>Updated list of confirmed El Principe de Gales cards (282)......Feb 18, 2009<br><br><br>Abbaticchio (brown sleeves)<br>Abbaticchio (blue sleeves)<br>Abbott<br>Adkins<br>Ames (hands/head)<br>Anderson<br>Atz<br>Baker<br>Ball (New York)<br>Ball (Cleveland)<br>Barbeau<br>Barger<br>Batch<br>Bates <br>Beaumont<br>Beck<br>Bell (hands/head)<br>Bender (portrait)<br>Bender (trees)<br>Bergen (bat)<br>Bergen (catching)<br>Berger<br>Bescher (fielding)<br>Blackburne<br>Bliss<br>Bowerman<br>B radley (portrait)<br>Bradley (bat)<br>Brain<br>Brashear<br>Bresnahan (bat)<br>Bresnahan (portrait)<br>Bridwell (cap)<br>Bridwell (no cap)<br>M. Brown (portrait)<br>M. Brown (Chicago)<br>Burch (fielding)<br>Burchell<br>Burke<br>Burns<br>Bush<b r>Camnitz (arms fold)<br>Camnitz (arms side)<br>Campbell<br>Casey<br>Chance (red portrait)<br>Chance (yellow portrait)<br>Chance (bat)<br>Chase (pink portrait)<br>Chase (white cap)<br>Chase (blue portrait)<br>Chase (dark cap)<br>Chesbro<br>Cicotte<br>Clarke (portrait)<br>Clarke (bat)<br>JJ Clarke<br>Cobb (red portrait)<br>Cobb (bat off)<br>Collins (A's)<br>Collins (Minneapolis)<br>Congalton<br>Conroy (bat)<br>Coveleski<br>Crandall (no cap)<br>Crandall (w/cap)<br>Cravath<br>Crawford (bat)<br>Cree<br>Criger<br>Dahlen (Boston)<br>Davidson<br>Geo Davis (Chicago)<br>Delehanty (Washington)<br>Demmitt (New York)<br>Devore<br>Donlin (bat)<br>Donlin (sitting)<br>Donovan (portrait)<br>Dooin<br>Doolan (bat)<br>Doolan (fielding)<br>Doolin<br>Dougherty (arm/air)<br>Downey (bat)<br>Joe Doyle (hands/head)<br>Larry Doyle (bat)<br>Larry Doyle (portrait)<br>Dubuc<br>Duffy<br>Dunn (Brooklyn)<br>Durham<br>Easterly<br>Egan<br>Elberf eld (Washington-fielding)<br>Evans<br>Evers (Chicago)<br>Evers (portrait)<br>Ewing<br>Fiene (portrait)<br>Fiene (throwing)<br>Flanagan<br>Ford<br>Freeman<br>Frill <br>Fromme<br>Gandil<br>Ganley<br>Gasper<br>Geyer< br>Gibson<br>Gilbert<br>Graham (Boston)<br>Graham (St Louis)<br>Gray<br>Griffith (portrait)<br>Groom<br>Hallman<br>Hannifan<br>Hart sell<br>Hemphill<br>Herzog (New York)<br>Herzog (Boston)<br>Hinchman (Cleveland)<br>Hinchman (Toronto)<br>Hoblitzell<br>Hofman<br>Howard (Chicago)<br>Howell (hands/waist)<br>Hulswitt<br>Hummell<br>Jackson<br>Jennin gs (portrait)<br>Jennings (1 hand)<br>Jennings (2 hands)<br>Johnson (portrait)<br>Johnson (pitching)<br>Tom Jones (St Louis)<br>Jordan (portrait)<br>Jordan (bat)<br>Joss (pitching)<br>Karger<br>Keeler (portrait)<br>Kelley<br>Killian (pitching)<br>Kisinger<br>Kleinow (Boston)<br>Kling<br>Knight (bat)<br>Konetchy (glove lo)<br>Konetchy (glove hi)<br>Krause (portrait)<br>Kruger<br>Lajoie (throwing)<br>Lajoie (bat)<br>Lake, St. Lou. (no ball)<br>Lake, St. Lou. (ball)<br>Lattimore<br>Lavender<br>Leach (portrait)<br>Leach (cap)<br>Leifield (pitching)<br>Leifeld (bat)<br>Lindaman<br>Livingstone<br>Lobert<br>Lord <br>Lumley<br>Lundgren (Cubs)<br>Lundgren (Kansas City)<br>Maddox<br>Magee (portrait)<br>Magee (bat)<br>Marquard (hands/side)<br>Mathewson (white cap)<br>Mathewson (dark cap)<br>Mattern<br>McAleese<br>McCormick<br>McGraw (portrait-w/cap)<br>McIntyre (Brooklyn/Chicago)<br>McLean<br>McQuillan (ball/hand)<br>Merritt<br>Meyers (portrait)<br>Miller (Pittsburg)<br>Milligan<br>Mullin (bat)<br>Mullin (throwing)<br>Murphy (bat)<br>Murray (portrait)<br>Myers (fielding)<br>Nattress<br>Needham<br>Nichols<br>Ni les<br>Oakes<br>Oberlin<br>O'Leary (portrait)<br>O'Leary (hands/knees)<br>Oldring (bat)<br>Overall (portrait)<br>Overall (yellow sky)<br>Overall (blue sky)<br>Owen<br>Payne<br>Pfeffer<br>Pfiester (seated)<br>Pfeister (throwing)<br>Phillippe<br>Powell<br>Purtell<br>Pu ttman<br>Quillen<br>Reulbach (no glove)<br>Raymond<br>Rhoades (hands/chest)<br>Rhoades (throwing)<br>Rhodes<br>Ritchey<br>Rucker (portrait)<br>Rudolph<br>Schaefer (Detroit)<br>Schlafly<br>Schlei (catching)<br>Schulte (back view)<br>Scott<br>Seymour (bat)<br>Schmidt (throwing)<br>Shannon<br>Sharpe<br>Shaw (St Louis)<br>Sheckard (glove)<br>Shipke<br>Smith (Brooklyn)<br>Smith (Buffalo)<br>F. Smith (Chicago)<br>Snodgrass (bat)<br>Snodgrass (catching)<br>Spade<br>Spencer<br>Stahl (glove)<br>Stanage<br>Steinfeldt (portrait)<br>Steinfeldt (bat)<br>Stephens<br>Stovall (portrait)<br>Stovall (bat)<br>Street (catching)<br>Sweeney (Boston)<br>Sweeney (New York)<br>L Tannehill<br>J Tannehill (Washington)<br>Taylor<br>Thomas<br>Tinker (portrait)<br>Tinker (bat off)<br>Tinker (bat on)<br>Titus<br>Turner<br>Wagner (bat/left)<br>Wagner (bat/right)<br>Walsh<br>Weimer<br>Wheat<br>White (Buffalo)<br>White (Chicago-port)<br>White (Chicago-pitching)<br>Wilhelm (arms/chest)<br>Wilhelm (bat)<br>Willett<br>Willetts<br>Willis (St Louis)<br>Willis (with bat)<br>Wilson<br>Wiltse (portrait-no cap)<br>Wiltse (pitching)<br>Wright<br>CYoung (portrait)<br>CYoung (bare hand)<br>CYoung (glove)<br>Zimmerman<br><br><br>TED Z<br><br>

Archive 02-18-2009 12:08 PM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>RayB</b><p>Of the confirmed examples is there a real way to distinguish which will be the toughest to acquire discounting pricing on the HOF'ers?<br>RayB

Archive 02-18-2009 04:44 PM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Scot Reader</b><p><br>Ray,<br><br>I'll take a stab at this. My survey data show the following:<br><br>150/350 group: 42 EPDG seen / 141 subjects in group = .30 per subject<br><br>350-only group: 51 EPDG seen / 207 subjects in group = .25 per subject<br><br>350/460 SP group: 5 EPDG seen / 6 subjects in group = .83 per subject<br><br>350/460 RP group: 20 EPDG seen / 55 subjects in group = .36 per subject<br><br>460-only group: 7 EPDG seen / 48 subjects in group = .15 per subject<br><br>So, EPDG difficulty is probably about the same across the various subject groups except that subjects in the 350/460 SP group are probably somewhat easier and subjects in the 460-only group are probably somewhat tougher.<br><br>Of course, this analysis assumes that all subjects in these groups are possible with EPDG. I didn't account for the no-prints.<br><br>Scot

Archive 02-19-2009 04:21 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>RayB</b><p>Scot. Thanks for your input.<br>I seem to recall a few particular cards that stood out as extremely difficult (but possible) in EPDG?

Archive 02-19-2009 05:44 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Ted Zanidakis</b><p>I would say the most scarcest EPDG backs are on these 8 cards in the 150/350 Series that I've (in a prior thread) <br>referred to them as the &quot;Elite Eight&quot;......<br><br>1st and foremost..Carl Lundgren (Cubs)....I acquired mine in 1984 and have seen only one other EPDG since then.<br><br>2nd......Mullin (throwing)<br><br>3rd......Dahlen (Boston)<br><br>4th......Ganley<br><br>5th......Ew ing<br><br>6th......Tom Jones (St Louis)<br><br>7th......Karger<br><br>8th......Lind aman<br><br><br><br>I have listed these in order of my experience in finding them with EPDG backs.<br><br>I'm open to any of your questions ?<br><br><br><br>TED Z<br><br><br>

Archive 02-19-2009 08:13 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Scot Reader</b><p><br>Ted, Ray:<br><br>I was thinking in terms of subject groups rather than individual subjects.<br><br>I agree with Ted about the &quot;elite eight&quot; 150/350 subjects. As they are very difficult with 350 backs (and in fact nonexistent with Sweet Caporal 350 and Sovereign 350 backs) it stands to reason that they would be extraordinarily difficult with EPDG.<br><br>Scot<br><br>

Archive 02-19-2009 09:08 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Tim</b><p>Scot and Ted, <br><br>According to an email I received from Ray a few days ago, he has both Dahlen (Boston) and Lindaman with an EPDG back.

Archive 02-19-2009 09:08 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Dave Hornish</b><p>Interesting that only 5 of 6 Super Prints have been seen with EPDG back.

Archive 02-19-2009 09:17 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Scot Reader</b><p><br>Dave,<br><br>All of the super prints have been confirmed with EPDG. My analysis was based only on my ebay survey data and did not include other data sources like Bill Brown's superset spreadsheet. The reason is that those other data sources don't tell you anything about quantity.<br><br>Scot

Archive 02-19-2009 09:26 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Dave Hornish</b><p>Ah-thanks for clarifying. I thought it odd.

Archive 02-19-2009 09:35 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Ted Zanidakis</b><p>I have all the 8 cards of the &quot;elite eight&quot; with EPDG backs and their very rare Piedmont 350 backs.<br><br>To acquire these two backs on these eight T206's is a task that took me over 4 years. As I noted<br> in my above post, Lundgren and Mullin are unbelievably tough with EPDG....finding these are a real<br> challenge.<br><br><br>TED Z<br><br>

Archive 02-19-2009 11:36 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Tim</b><p>Ted and Scot,<br><br>Rather than get off track from Rays EPDG topic, can one of you start a new thread and discuss the &quot;Elite Eight&quot; specifically.<br><br>Thank you.<br><br>

Archive 02-19-2009 01:14 PM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Ted Zanidakis</b><p>TIM<br><br>I have posted previous threads on these 8 cards; but, searching for them is not always easy. However, I <br>don't want to start another thread. Therefore,, here is a summary of my findings on these 8 cards.<br><br>So, here is what I've found about these 8 cards in the 150/350 series. Compared to the other 133 cards<br> in the 150/350 series, these 8 cards are very seldom found with a &quot;350&quot; back.<br><br> These 8 cards are found with the usual &quot;150&quot; backs (HINDU, PIEDMONT 150, SOVEREIGN 150, and SWEET<br> CAPORAL 150). But, are rarely found with a 350 back....and then, it is only a PIEDMONT 350 back.<br> Furthermore, the only other &quot;350&quot; back is the EPDG (and this is very rare). <br><br> The following is a survey we ran on these 8 cards a few years ago that provides you a relative perspect-<br>ive on what I am saying here.<br><br><br><br>Subject................Piedmo nt 350......HINDU........EPDG....Sweet Cap 350....150/350 inputs (total)<br><br><br>Dahlen (Boston)...............4.............3............ ..1...............0.................155<br><br>Ewi ng............................1..............1.... ..........1...............0.................198<br ><br>Ganley...........................3........... ...1..............2...............0............... ....99<br><br>T Jones (St Louis)............2..............2..............2. ..............0.................141<br><br>Karger. ...........................4..............0....... .......4...............0.................167<br><b r>Lindaman........................3..............5 ..............4...............0.................12 8<br><br>Lundgren (Cubs)..............4..............0.............. 2...............0...................55<br><br>Mull in (throw)..................2..............0......... .....4...............0...................86<br><br ><br><br>Totals...........................23...... .......12............20..............0............ ....1129<br><br><br>TED Z<br><br>

Archive 02-19-2009 02:13 PM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>RayB</b><p>I've got:<br><br>Dahlen (Boston)<br>T.Jones<br>Karger<br>Lindaman<br><br>i n EPDG Back.<br><br>Not sure I had all of those when we originally did the survey.<br>Thanks for refreshing that info Ted.<br>RayB

Archive 02-19-2009 05:33 PM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Tim</b><p>Ted -<br><br>Have you been able to determine any connection between the &quot;Elite Eight&quot; that would explain their scarcity?

Archive 02-19-2009 06:57 PM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>RayB</b><p>Just happened to have these two both on my hard drive.<br><br><img src="http://www.network54.com/Realm/tmp/1235098472.JPG" alt="[linked image]"> <img src="http://www.network54.com/Realm/tmp/1235098510.JPG" alt="[linked image]">

Archive 02-20-2009 09:13 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Ted Zanidakis</b><p>With the exception of Mullin....the other 7 Subject's careers were in a state of transition in 1909 and this,<br> perhaps, caused American Litho. (ALCo) not to extend their printing of these particular Subjects with the <br>usual &quot;350&quot; type of T-brands. When a new series was introduced, ALCo printed the Piedmont brand first;<br> therefore, a limited number of Piedmont 350 backs were issued of these 8 cards. Furthermore, I would say <br>it is evident from these 8 cards that the EPDG back shortly followed in the print run.<br><br>This information may offer some insight regarding these Subjects......<br><br>1..Dahlen played in only 69 games with the Boston Doves in 1909, and then was traded to Brooklyn.<br><br>2..Ewing was traded from Cinci to the Phillies at the end of 1909.<br><br>3..Ganley was traded from Washington to the A's in May 1909.<br><br>4..Tom Jones was traded from St Louis (AL) to Detroit in Aug 1909.<br><br>5..Karger was traded from Cinci to Boston (AL) in Jun 1909.<br><br>6..Lindaman was sent down to Indy (Amer. Assoc.) in July 1909, after a 1-6 record with Boston (NL).<br><br>7..Lundgren's Maj. Lge. career ended Apr 23rd 1909, after having pitched in only 2 games for the Cubs.<br><br>8..Mullin had a AL leading 29-8 pitching record in 1909...can't figure why this card is in this group ? ? <br><img src="http://i529.photobucket.com/albums/dd339/tz1234zaz/a150eliteeight350b.jpg" alt="[linked image]"><br><br>POST SCRIPT......<br><br>After several years of searching for the Piedmont 350 versions of these 8 cards, I was able to acquire 7 of<br> them from one original collection from Georgia. This T206 collection consisted of all Piedmont 350 cards.....<br>including the very rare Joe Doyle error card.....what does this fact tell us ?<br><br><br><br><br>TED Z<br><br>

Archive 02-20-2009 10:51 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>keyway</b><p>I have a EPDG Lundgren, Chicago graded SGC 30. Bought this card back in the mid 80's. I guess you can add this to your list of amounts. Frank

Archive 02-20-2009 10:59 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Lee Behrens</b><p>Ted if you are adding to the list I own a Ewing EPDG, I believe I let you know initially but since I have seen one for sale on Ebay, so that would make at least 2.<br><br>Lee

Archive 02-20-2009 02:29 PM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Ted Zanidakis</b><p>Thanks for your EPDG inputs. But, I'm not running this survey anow. I posted the above data for illustrative<br> purposes, only. That data is over a year old. The intervening gap between then and now makes it unrealistic<br> to continue this survey at this point.<br><br>FRANK<br><br>Your Lundgren with an EPDG back is only the 3rd one I know of in 25 years of searching for another one.<br>It appears like you acquired yours about the same time I acquired mine back in the 1980's.<br><br>TED Z<br><br>

Archive 02-20-2009 05:53 PM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>keyway</b><p>Ted; The one I have was bought in Ct. I don't know if they are found in one area or not. Thanks for the info. Frank

Archive 02-21-2009 06:39 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Ted Zanidakis</b><p>Thanks for the info. My Lundgren was acquired in the NY-NJ area.<br><br>TED Z<br><br>

Archive 02-21-2009 06:40 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Ted Zanidakis</b><p>This list is being reprised to add a new entry and raise a question on the Adkins input....can any one confirm Adkins ?<br><br>Updated list of confirmed El Principe de Gales cards (283)......Feb 21, 2009<br><br><br>Abbaticchio (brown sleeves)<br>Abbaticchio (blue sleeves)<br>Abbott<br>Adkins...................... .............? ?<br>Ames (hands/head)<br>Anderson<br>Atz<br>Baker<br>Ball (New York)<br>Ball (Cleveland)<br>Barbeau<br>Barger<br>Batch<br>Bates <br>Beaumont<br>Beck<br>Bell (hands/head)<br>Bender (portrait)<br>Bender (trees)<br>Bergen (bat)<br>Bergen (catching)<br>Berger<br>Bescher (fielding)<br>Blackburne<br>Bliss<br>Bowerman<br>B radley (portrait)<br>Bradley (bat)<br>Brain<br>Brashear<br>Bresnahan (bat)<br>Bresnahan (portrait)<br>Bridwell (cap)<br>Bridwell (no cap)<br>M. Brown (portrait)<br>M. Brown (Chicago)<br>Burch (fielding)<br>Burchell<br>Burke<br>Burns<br>Bush<b r>Camnitz (arms fold)<br>Camnitz (arms side)<br>Campbell<br>Casey<br>Chance (red portrait)<br>Chance (yellow portrait)<br>Chance (bat)<br>Chase (pink portrait)<br>Chase (white cap)<br>Chase (blue portrait)<br>Chase (dark cap)<br>Chesbro<br>Cicotte<br>Clarke (portrait)<br>Clarke (bat)<br>JJ Clarke<br>Cobb (red portrait)<br>Cobb (bat off)<br>Collins (A's)<br>Collins (Minneapolis)<br>Congalton<br>Conroy (bat)<br>Coveleski<br>Crandall (no cap)<br>Crandall (w/cap)<br>Cravath<br>Crawford (bat)<br>Cree<br>Criger<br>Dahlen (Boston)<br>Davidson<br>Geo Davis (Chicago)<br>Delehanty (Washington)<br>Demmitt (New York)<br>Devore<br>Donlin (bat)<br>Donlin (sitting)<br>Donovan (portrait)<br>Dooin<br>Doolan (bat)<br>Doolan (fielding)<br>Doolin<br>Dougherty (arm/air)<br>Downey (bat)<br>Joe Doyle (hands/head)<br>Larry Doyle (bat)<br>Larry Doyle (portrait)<br>Dubuc<br>Duffy<br>Dunn (Baltimore)..........................new input<br>Dunn (Brooklyn)<br>Durham<br>Easterly<br>Egan<br>Elberf eld (Washington-fielding)<br>Evans<br>Evers (Chicago)<br>Evers (portrait)<br>Ewing<br>Fiene (portrait)<br>Fiene (throwing)<br>Flanagan<br>Ford<br>Freeman<br>Frill <br>Fromme<br>Gandil<br>Ganley<br>Gasper<br>Geyer< br>Gibson<br>Gilbert<br>Graham (Boston)<br>Graham (St Louis)<br>Gray<br>Griffith (portrait)<br>Groom<br>Hallman<br>Hannifan<br>Hart sell<br>Hemphill<br>Herzog (New York)<br>Herzog (Boston)<br>Hinchman (Cleveland)<br>Hinchman (Toronto)<br>Hoblitzell<br>Hofman<br>Howard (Chicago)<br>Howell (hands/waist)<br>Hulswitt<br>Hummell<br>Jackson<br>Jennin gs (portrait)<br>Jennings (1 hand)<br>Jennings (2 hands)<br>Johnson (portrait)<br>Johnson (pitching)<br>Tom Jones (St Louis)<br>Jordan (portrait)<br>Jordan (bat)<br>Joss (pitching)<br>Karger<br>Keeler (portrait)<br>Kelley<br>Killian (pitching)<br>Kisinger<br>Kleinow (Boston)<br>Kling<br>Knight (bat)<br>Konetchy (glove lo)<br>Konetchy (glove hi)<br>Krause (portrait)<br>Kruger<br>Lajoie (throwing)<br>Lajoie (bat)<br>Lake, St. Lou. (no ball)<br>Lake, St. Lou. (ball)<br>Lattimore<br>Lavender<br>Leach (portrait)<br>Leach (cap)<br>Leifield (pitching)<br>Leifeld (bat)<br>Lindaman<br>Livingstone<br>Lobert<br>Lord <br>Lumley<br>Lundgren (Cubs)<br>Lundgren (Kansas City)<br>Maddox<br>Magee (portrait)<br>Magee (bat)<br>Marquard (hands/side)<br>Mathewson (white cap)<br>Mathewson (dark cap)<br>Mattern<br>McAleese<br>McCormick<br>McGraw (portrait-w/cap)<br>McIntyre (Brooklyn/Chicago)<br>McLean<br>McQuillan (ball/hand)<br>Merritt<br>Meyers (portrait)<br>Miller (Pittsburg)<br>Milligan<br>Mullin (bat)<br>Mullin (throwing)<br>Murphy (bat)<br>Murray (portrait)<br>Myers (fielding)<br>Nattress<br>Needham<br>Nichols<br>Ni les<br>Oakes<br>Oberlin<br>O'Leary (portrait)<br>O'Leary (hands/knees)<br>Oldring (bat)<br>Overall (portrait)<br>Overall (yellow sky)<br>Overall (blue sky)<br>Owen<br>Payne<br>Pfeffer<br>Pfiester (seated)<br>Pfeister (throwing)<br>Phillippe<br>Powell<br>Purtell<br>Pu ttman<br>Quillen<br>Reulbach (no glove)<br>Raymond<br>Rhoades (hands/chest)<br>Rhoades (throwing)<br>Rhodes<br>Ritchey<br>Rucker (portrait)<br>Rudolph<br>Schaefer (Detroit)<br>Schlafly<br>Schlei (catching)<br>Schulte (back view)<br>Scott<br>Seymour (bat)<br>Schmidt (throwing)<br>Shannon<br>Sharpe<br>Shaw (St Louis)<br>Sheckard (glove)<br>Shipke<br>Smith (Brooklyn)<br>Smith (Buffalo)<br>F. Smith (Chicago)<br>Snodgrass (bat)<br>Snodgrass (catching)<br>Spade<br>Spencer<br>Stahl (glove)<br>Stanage<br>Steinfeldt (portrait)<br>Steinfeldt (bat)<br>Stephens<br>Stovall (portrait)<br>Stovall (bat)<br>Street (catching)<br>Sweeney (Boston)<br>Sweeney (New York)<br>L Tannehill<br>J Tannehill (Washington)<br>Taylor<br>Thomas<br>Tinker (portrait)<br>Tinker (bat off)<br>Tinker (bat on)<br>Titus<br>Turner<br>Wagner (bat/left)<br>Wagner (bat/right)<br>Walsh<br>Weimer<br>Wheat<br>White (Buffalo)<br>White (Chicago-port)<br>White (Chicago-pitching)<br>Wilhelm (arms/chest)<br>Wilhelm (bat)<br>Willett<br>Willetts<br>Willis (St Louis)<br>Willis (with bat)<br>Wilson<br>Wiltse (portrait-no cap)<br>Wiltse (pitching)<br>Wright<br>CYoung (portrait)<br>CYoung (bare hand)<br>CYoung (glove)<br>Zimmerman<br><br><br>TED Z<br><br>

Archive 03-03-2009 06:21 PM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Anonymous</b><p>Ted,<br><br>Add manning Pitching to the list.<br><br>RayB<br><br><br><br>

Archive 03-04-2009 05:18 AM

T206 EPDG Back Question
 
Posted By: <b>Ted Zanidakis</b><p>Thanks......we are up to 284 confirmed EPDG backs.<br><br><br>RAY....I have abbreviated your URL of this ebay lot to this one....please shorten yours as such.<br><br><a href="http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&amp;item=370163006836" target="_new" rel="nofollow">http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&amp;item=370163006836</a><br><br><br>Thanks again,<br><br>TED Z<br><br>

Theoldprofessor 05-23-2009 01:12 PM

Ted;

Please add to your humongous EPDG list:

Keeler with bat

(Unless 37 others have already found him. Then forget the whole thing)

Bob


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:46 AM.