Net54baseball.com Forums

Net54baseball.com Forums (http://www.net54baseball.com/index.php)
-   Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions (http://www.net54baseball.com/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Pre1925 Top 35 List (http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=91582)

Archive 12-21-2008 06:42 PM

Pre1925 Top 35 List
 
Posted By: <b>Tim Kindler</b><p>A couple of weeks ago I was laid up with Strep Throat and the Flu. In my boredom, I was reading Joe Orlando's Top 100 Sportscards of All-Time book. Overall, I find it pretty good reading. Anyway, I came up with this idea to compile my own list of the top Pre 1925 cards. I tried to keep it small, but it quickly became too hard to squeeze to 25, so I made it 35! <br><br>I based my Top 35 on 5 Criteria: 1. Apperance 2.Popularity 3.Rarity 4. Value-Both Historically and Monetary 5. Envy, Desire, and One's dream of owning knowing most of us will never own one.<br><br>This list is just for kicks and giggles and just wanted to see what others think about it. Do you agree? Am I crazy for including some? Am I crazy for leaving some off, and which ones? I thought it would be fun here at the end of the year while everyone else has some sort of top whatever list! ENJOY!<br><br>1.T206 Wagner <br>2.E90-1 Jackson <br>3.T206 Cobb Green Backed <br>4.M101-5 Ruth <br>5.Craker Jack Jackson <br>6.N28 Cap Anson <br>7.T205 Cobb <br>8.T206 Johnson Portrait <br>9.T3 Cobb 1<br>10.E90-2 Wagner <br>11.Craker Jack Cobb <br>12.D304 Brunner's Bread Cobb<br>13.T227 Cobb <br>14.T206 Plank <br>15.T210 Jackson <br>16.N172 OJ $10,000 Kelly <br>17.T204 Ramly Johnson<br>18.M101-5 Thorpe<br>19. E94 Cobb-Purple Bkgd.<br>20. Tip Top Wagner <br>21. 1914 Baltimore News Ruth<br>22.1910 Obak Weaver<br>23.Cracker Jack Mathewson- Throwing<br>24.T222 Fatima G.C. Alexander<br>25.E98 Mathewson- Red Bkgd.<br>26.E97 Sullivan Boston Error<br>27.1911 Mack E104 Nadja/Various Backs<br>28.E102 Wagner- Batting<br>29.T205 Mathewson<br>30.E121 Ruth- Holding Bird<br>31.T202 Hassan Triple Folder Cobb<br>32.N172 OJ Ewing and Mascot<br>33. E95 Plank<br>34.N172 OJ Delehanty<br>35.T205 Hoblitzell No Stats<br> <br><br>

Archive 12-21-2008 08:16 PM

Pre1925 Top 35 List
 
Posted By: <b>leon</b><p>Hi Tim<br>Nice list. A board member and I were discussing a Top 20 Pre-War cards very recently but I don't remember each one we had on it, exactly. Everyone can have their own ideas on this subject and I doubt any would be wrong. <br>I would add a few to the list, and I am sure I will leave some great ones out...<br><br>1. N690 Four Base Hits Kelly<br>2. N-Unc Just So Cy Young<br>3. N690 Kalamazoo Bats Ewing<br>4. N172 Anson in uniform<br>5. H-Unc 1869 Peck and Snyder Red Stockings<br>6. E107 Wagner<br>7. E107 Mathewson<br>8. E224 Texas Tommy Jackson<br>9. E137 Zeenut Thorpe<br>10.N370 Comisky<br>11.E223 Reach and Spalding<br><br>12.D381 Wagner (personal favorite..not in the same value range)<br>etc, etc...<br><br>*I reserve the right to come back and add a few more. <br> <br><br>regards<br>leon<br><br><br><br>

Archive 12-21-2008 09:02 PM

Pre1925 Top 35 List
 
Posted By: <b>Jay</b><p>Here is my top 10 list of pre-war cards:<br><br>1. T206 Wagner<br>2. Baltimore News Ruth<br>3. Anson in Uniform<br>4. Just So Young<br>5. T210 Jackson<br>6. Rare Third N172 Pose of Harry Wright (Explained in OJ Book)<br>7. Four Base Hits Kelly<br>8. Kelly N172 Players League Card<br>9. E107 Mathewson<br>10. N173 Kelly in Street Clothes<br><br>Honorable Mention: T206 Plank, Ramley Johnson, N167 Ewing<br>


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:38 PM.