1910 Dalton PA All Star Baseball Team Christy Mathewson
 

Hi, Could anyone identify these baseball players? I think I have 2 figured out. Christy Mathewson and Tim Samuel Strothers. I was also wondering what the team emblems might be. 2 photos attached. Thank you in advance, Maggie.

Photo
 

I hope for your sake, one of them is Chrity Mathewson, but I personally am not seeing a connection.

Which one do you think is Matty?

Tony

I don't see Matty at all and to top it off these are all kids. Mathewson was a 30 year old pitching for the New York Giants in 1910.

The player in the white hat at right. Photo is from Dalton near Factoryville.
African American looks like Tim Sam Strothers, the catcher? Thanks!

T,

The kid in the white hat looks like he's 16.

Picture
 

Cool Photo, but not sure where you are getting either Strothers or Matty from... both would have been in their 30's...

attached is a link to a photo of Strothers:


http://agatetype.typepad.com/.a/6a00...dc5c970b-popup

Sorry to say it, but Christy Mathewson is not in this photo.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

Eh, close enough. Great Matty!

troublemaker :)

Post the whole pic and maybe someone here can find an identifiable feature to point you in a direction but your IDs are definitely not correct.

:D

Thank you for all the replies. There appears to be both men and boys in the negative photo. The African American's emblem is CA? Chicago American Giants? Strothers played for them as a catcher.

Photo
 

I don't see Matty at all, but that horse in the background looks like Joe Jackson:D

Tony

That's definitely not Strothers, and not the Chicago American Giants logo. While a real nice photograph, it's a kid's team and like everyone else has said, there isn't any way that is Matty nor Strothers. Still a nice photo, appreciate it for what it is.

ok, thanks again!