Show us your disappointments
 

I've only had two. But I've had more where PSA didn't even know what it was.

Kind of a high dollar disappointment on the Sporting News card. I have had a few Fro Joys and Babe Ruth Candy cards kicked back but nothing that wasn't iffy to start with :). We all have our closet of pics of their mistakes but the great majority of times the big TPGs get it right (as to authenticity).

This was supposed to be the t213-3 for my Evers yellow sky back run. It’s real banged up indeed, but I was hoping to at least get a 1 or slabbed A. Nope, it came back like this. Seller gave me a full refund, but I am still looking for my type 3 (need the overstrike too).

Greatest disappointments?
 

Probably the 2002 World Series.
Giants lost to a stupid rally monkey...

What does the judgment say on the flip??

It says “altered”. I submitted 4 cards, and asked to slab anything authentic. They slabbed an Evers yellow sky Sov 460 with an entire corner clipped off, but they would not/did not slab this one.

It reads "ALTERED" from my view. The default when anyone submits to PSA is that they won't slab Altered cards unless you include the direction in text on the form. I put "PLEASE SLAB ALL CARDS IF AUTHENTIC" at the bottom of my forms.

The Best!
 

That was my best World Series! Went to all 7 games and finally my Angels won!!