Can a 1931 W517 fit in a standard top loader?
 

I am thinking of purchasing a raw 1931 W517 card for my collection.

Can these cards fit in a standard top loader (below)? Thank you!

https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/tc4AA...Hnc/s-l300.jpg

I don't think so. The W517 cards I have are in Card Saver 1 sleeves, which were designed to fit 1952 to 1956 sized cards. It is still a tight fit. The Card Saver 2 sleeves, which are comparable in size to the the toploaders you show, are not big enough.

Brian

No they are too big. I tend to put them I think 4x6 or 5x7 top loaders. Hope this helps.

Just trim it down. Problem solved.

HAHA!!!

Thank you boys!

Hey, while I'm at it

Are there any other particular pre 1935 set cards that I should avoid in this top loader scenario?

Example; Could a 1930 W554 fit in this type of top loader? Your help is much appreciated,

W554's are 5"x7" and won't fit in the top loaders that you showed from your first post.

None of the Exhibit cards will fit either...

You can always check the Old Cardboard website - they list the dimensions in the descriptions for each card listed.

http://www.oldcardboard.com/