I agree Matt, the one in the link you posted is better looking to me as well.

Sincerely, Clayton

I think it would have a better look if it were in black and white the blue hat and socks stick out like a sore thumb.

I like the original but I like the one Matthew posted even more. And I agree, the thought didn't escape me on it potentially helping the pre-war hobby. I like almost anything that will help folks get excited about our hobby.

I like it.
 

I really like the Gypsy Queen minis. I have several of the Cincinnati Reds cards from this set, including a handful of autographs.

I like the Ruth image and those Mini Leather cards have a really cool texture to them.

It would be a lot better if it had some saw dust from a game-used bat or something . . .

I kind of like the way it looks, I've always liked the grittier pictures on baseball cards, hell on anything for that matter.
Defiently wouldn't fork out 250 for it though.

I think I would have liked it more if the colors were the same as the originals...

Ricky Y

Interesting thread. Does anyone with a VCP account have some completed auction realized prices to share for this Ruth and any of the other Pre-war HOFers /10 in that Gypsy Queen mini leather set? It would be nice to know what the market values these cards. Thanks.

Interesting numbers. I wonder if the card being polled were the one Matthew showed later in this thread, would the numbers be materially different?

I like some new cards with vintage players, but I had to vote against the OP card. It just didn't grab me at all.