Should I, or another moderator, bid in the Net54baseball.com auctions?
 

I just won a card, in one of our Net54 live auctions. I need it for my Obak 150 series subset. It got me to thinking ....Would someone not bid against me as I am the peasant/ forum owner or because they see a high bidder is a moderator? I would hope they would care less, but could it affect the final prices negatively? If other moderators, or I, don't bid might THAT keep the prices down? This might be a conundrum.:eek:

As the dude whose auction you just won, yes, by all means you should bid.

If it's a conundrum, why ask why?:eek:

Anthony
 

Thanks....we will see what others say too. I would feel bad if someone didn't realize the best price they thought they could get and it was because others didn't bid against me. That would suck. Maybe I am dreaming and that would never happen but it just crossed my mind ....I think the card I won is about equal to the level I won it ast, maybe $20 more on a decent day. I do track them a little bit. I see the 150 series be about 2x-4x of regular 175 series....

Brad
 

I dunno....maybe because that is what intelligent people do?

Do you really think anyone on this board won't bid because they might be bidding against you?

Do you think that has happened in the past with Ebay, or other auction houses?

As long as you're not "fooling" with the others posts and bids, I don't have any problem with it (assuming, of course, that you confine yourself to Lajoie and Cobb cards and stay away from NY Giants Schedule Postcards!)

Leon,

Why segregate yourself from the other members, we all know whos running the show!!! so you bidding would make no difference;)

should I bid
 

I see no problem with it at all. I feel its an auction and anyone be it moderator or member has a chance to bid on the item and let the final bid take it. Now if you tell me the forum owner can control the last bid well then I guess we might have a problem:D:D:D:eek::eek::eek::):)

should i...
 

I don't see a problem with you bidding. I do think some people might be reluctant to bid if they can't do so anonymously though.

No problems if you bid in my opinion. I'm not scared of you Leon. :D

No problem here either.

I see no issue at all. Bid away.

total transperancy
 

I have no magic wand in the auctions. Thanks for the feedback. We will see how the Net54baseball.com live auctions go. So far so good (knock on wood). I am optimistic....thanks for the feedback guys..!! http://cdn.content.sweetim.com/sim/c...s/00020058.gif

Ok with me
 

It is OK with me as long as you don't use your Quarter you use on post! D.

We are all collectors
 

Everybody should be given the opportunity to bid.

I don't see an issue with it at all. It wouldn't keep me from bidding unless it results in getting banned. :)

Leon, if I see YOU bidding I will bid even more just to beat you!:)
-Rhett

Here's a somewhat similar card won on ebay a few months back and the price was similar... I say bid away

http://tinyurl.com/mrpqty

At least there where your name is out in the open, it's better than bidding in a private or catalog auction that you might run.

Since these are public auctions so to speak
 

Then everyone -- including Lee Behrens on Jay's material and vice versa should be able to bid.

This is as close to old school auctions of the 1980's as we will see

Regards
Rich

Old school auctions were like a black hole - you didn't know who else was bidding, how much they bid, who won, and sometimes not even what the winning bid was. This is almost the opposite of that, other then the similarity that it's run by individual collectors instead of an auction house.

My apologies
 

I meant the public auctions of the 1980's; usually held in an hotel or as part of a show.

My bad for not making that clear

Rich

If Bill Mastro can bid on Mastro auctions, why can't you bid on Net 54 auctions? It's not like you know the ceiling bids, right? :)

Matt
 

I think what Rich was really meaning is that these auctions are actually fun. From reading hundreds of old trade rags I totally agree with you though on how there used to be time lapses and a big black hole in information pertaining to auctions. These are in fact opposite in that respect. These are totally transparent. I like how:

1. I am not involved in any rules. (except my own auctions)
2. So far everyone is having total transparency (can't get any better imo)
3. So far there haven't been any big issues.

I am glad our members thought of this idea. Thanks to all who are participating. I wonder if that section will out grow the others?

TY Leon
 

That is exactly what I meant. Believe it or not; the public auctions of the 1980's were a lot of fun to attend. And these auctions are the closest thing to those events.

Geez; you'd think I'd stop for a second sometimes :)

Rich

Jeff
 

I had a friendly debate with a board member last night about this very subject. He is not affiliated with any auction house at all but is a very passionate collector for the last 35 yrs. He sees no issue with auction company employees bidding in their own auctions. I have never thought that was a good idea, personally. Ceiling bids? Unless I am a mind reader I can't see me knowing anymore than anyone else...

Even in B and L Auctions Scott and I made a rule from day one that we can't see any up to bids and we can't bid in our own auctions. Of course every auction company will do what is best for them and we feel this is the best route for us...

And on a different vein
 

I concur that getting these auctions up and going is a fine idea. Most of us have no way of really dealing with the "non major auction material" and this allows another outlet. And we got up quickly as well. I hope that any further advances when needed to this board come as quickly :)

Rich

Ahh - I was thinking older school - from the 70's :)

What if you don't need to be a mind reader to see ceiling bids? Just have eyes that work?

Jeff
 

I was talking about Net54baseball.com auctions. Where are my eyes supposed to look?

Exactly, Leon. That's why it's ok for you to bid on Net 54 auctions and not ok for other auctioneers to bid on their auctions.

Moderators
 

Absolutely should be allowed to bid.

I think it's fine for Leon to bid, and it's fine for others to bid against him. My only objection would be if others chose not to bid against Leon. As perhaps noted before, it would be someone else's auction Leon would be bidding in, not his own, and he and the other moderators get 0% financial return from sales and auctions that are not their own. The commonly held issue with auction house employees bidding in their own auction house's auctions is due to the auction house receiving a percentage of the final prices.

1. Leon and the other moderators should be able to bid, so long as their identity is not concealed. Same thing if they're selling.

2. If there is ever a fee or commission that the seller or buyer pays to the board, then at that time site owners and administrators should not be allowed to bid. And the same if they're selling.

3. I would have no problem bidding against Leon if it was a card I wanted.

I agree with Frank on all of his three points.

You should only bid on them
 

if you want to win them; in other words, I don't have an issue with it.

Besides, none of us respect you enough to refrain from bidding if we see you in there anyway. :D

No worries
 

I have no concerns about moderators bidding in those auctions as it is all transparent and I think others will happily bid against you

Leon,

Yourself, Dan, and Brian are more than welcome to get into a bidding war on anything I might put up for auction :D

I don't see why you shouldn't bid on something that you are interested in.

I left out one more circumstance under which Leon and the others should not be allowed to bid or auction... And that would be if and when they start slabbing / grading cards. If they start that they shouldn't bid on cards they've graded, and they shouldn't sell any cards.

So as long as they're not in the card grading business, as long as this site doesn't charge fees for auctions, and if they're identity is clear, then have at it!!!

I have no problem with Leon bidding...the problem I have is when he is bidding against me!!

Joshua

I see no problem with you bidding on any of the auctions. As far as you being a moderator i don't see that being an advantage or disadvantage. I would not feel threatend or intimidated buy your bid,if you or anybody out bids me no problem.

Leon,

You think we wont bid against you becaue you're YOU? Now that's funny. We all love you, man. But we aint gonna hold back if we want something. You're funny...

Sure you should bid, especially if I'm selling :D. not so much if I am bidding.. :eek: