Your opinion of this 1933 Goudey ??
 

The waner pictured on the right- please sneak a look. Cards not mine but posted by a well known collector on teh CU boards and I want added opinions before posting my own thoughts over there. I have doubts even to its authenticity and rather than cloud or interfere others opinions I'd prefer waiting until yoru all done speaking before offering the 'whys" on why I have those doubts. The include everything from print, paper, coloring etc

In short everything I don't want to see on a Goudey is screaming at me on this one

Others opinions appreciated = I've been looking at Goudeys since 1969 but hey old man now so my eyes are not what they used to be :D

I'd like to hear from people about their own experiences/thoughts before gathering my own into a more concise detailed explanation to this collector on that CU board.

While I am hoping I am incorrect - too many head shakers for me to not ask for additional "opinions" before expressing to this collector my own thoughts. If I am wrong than I'll have learned new stuff and wont be the first tiem either- Goudeys are not my thing hence why I'm asking you folks for your own thoughts.


[IMG]https://www.freedomcardboard.com/for...3&d=1565018485[/IMG]

Seems like the Waner may have been cleaned...

Soaked in bleach, spooned and trimmed. you're basic salon visit.

Real, but I suspect some doctoring as well. Are there scans of the back?