Colgan's Chips Photo Question
 

Can anyone confirm the following about the photos on Colgan's Chips:
1. Kelly - Toronto is NOT Joe Kelley HOF'er?
2. Freeman - Toledo is NOT Jerry but Buck?
Any help would be greatly appreciated and thanks in advance,
Tony

I haven't seen the Colgan's image, but Kelly - Toronto COULD be Joe Kelley, the HOFer. After his major league career, he did play in the minors with Toronto in 1909 - 1910. (His T206 card is from Toronto). Don't know about the spelling difference?

There are photos of the 2 cards on Oldcardboard's site (in the gallery) if anyone wants to see them for referrence.

That is Buck Freeman - same photo as his E107.

That is not HoF'er Joe Kelley, though he was with Toronto at that time. I don't know who it is.

Check out this old thread, in it I discuss a few Colgan's "wrong-fronts" including the Kelly/Kelley card...
http://net54baseball.com/showthread....s+kelley+image