PDA

View Full Version : test your ballcard ID skills....

Archive
03-14-2009, 05:05 PM
Posted By: <b>Frank Wakefield</b><p>21 cards...<br><br>Hints... #7 has a blue caption, the last 4 were distributed in another country.<br><br>wish you well with it...<br><br>1-<br>2-<br>3-<br>4-<br>5-<br>6-<br>7-<br>8-<br>9-<br>10-<br>11-<br>12-<br>13-<br>14-<br>15-<br>16-<br>17-<br>18-<br>19-<br>20-<br>21-<br><br><img src="http://i78.photobucket.com/albums/j106/greatwake/stufflittle.jpg" alt="[linked image]">
Archive
03-14-2009, 05:19 PM
Posted By: <b>Michael Steele</b><p>Hi Frank,<br><br>Hey a couple of Red sox in there. I will knock out #1 and #12<br><br>#1 1936 Goudey R322 Rick Ferrell <br>#12 E90-1 Ed Karger
Archive
03-14-2009, 05:21 PM
Posted By: <b>JDRUM</b><p>1. 1936 Goudey Rick Ferrell<br>2. WG4/5 GC Alexander<br>3. E120 Walter Mails<br>4. E120 Austin McHenry<br>5. E126 Aaron Ward<br>6. Helmar Stamp ?<br>7. Coupon Ira Thomas<br>8. W574 Bill Sillinger<br>9. 1933 DelOng Jimmy Foxx<br>10. E121 Heilmann<br>11. ?<br>12. E90-1 Bergen<br>13. ?<br>14. ?<br>15. ?<br>16. ?<br>17. ?<br>18. Neilson's Type 1 or 2 Wally Schang<br>19. V100 Harry Hooper<br>20. 1933 WWG Jack Quinn<br>21. 1934 WWG Chuck Klein<br><br>
Archive
03-14-2009, 05:43 PM
Posted By: <b>Frank Wakefield</b><p>Pretty good so far....<br><br><br>1. MIchael***** R3221936 Goudey Rick Ferrell<br>2. JDRUM**** WG4/5 GC Alexander<br>3. JDRUM**** E120 Walter Mails bidding on this card is how I got my eBay name, and the name here...<br>4. JDRUM**** E120 Austin McHenry an interesting player<br>5. JDRUM**** E126 Aaron Ward<br>6. JDRUM* Helmar Stamp, YES, but who???? <br>7. JDRUM** T213 Coupon Ira Thomas<br>8. JDRUM**** W574 Bill Sillinger<br>9. JDRUM**** 1933 DelOng Jimmy Foxx<br>10. JDRUM**** E121 Heilmann<br>11. ?<br>12. Michael**** E90-1 Karger, a tough card -1* for JDRUM<br>13. ?<br>14. ?<br>15. ?<br>16. ?<br>17. ?<br>18. JDRUM**** Neilson's Wally Schang, the shiny front one<br>19. JDRUM**** V100 Harry Hooper good eye<br>20. JDRUM**** 1933 World Wide Gum Jack Quinn<br>21. JDRUM**** 1934 World Wide Gum Chuck Klein
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:01 PM
Posted By: <b>Bob Manning</b><p>12. W 512 Dazzy Vance?
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:03 PM
Posted By: <b>barrysloate</b><p>#16 and #17 are W514.<br><br>Should say #16 is W514 Buck Weaver. Now not sure about #17.
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:17 PM
Posted By: <b>Frank Wakefield</b><p>Bob, I think you intended #13... and that isn't Dazzy Vance. But it is a member of the HOF.<br><br>#17 is not a W514, Barry, but the player is in the HOF.<br><br>1. MIchael***** R3221936 Goudey Rick Ferrell<br>2. JDRUM**** WG4/5 GC Alexander<br>3. JDRUM**** E120 Walter Mails bidding on this card is how I got my eBay name, and the name here...<br>4. JDRUM**** E120 Austin McHenry an interesting player<br>5. JDRUM**** E126 Aaron Ward<br>6. JDRUM* Helmar Stamp, YES, but who????<br>7. JDRUM** T213 Coupon Ira Thomas<br>8. JDRUM**** W574 Bill Sillinger<br>9. JDRUM**** 1933 DelOng Jimmy Foxx<br>10. JDRUM**** E121 Heilmann<br>11. ?<br>12. Michael**** E90-1 Karger, a tough card -1* for JDRUM<br>13. ?<br>14. ?<br>15. ?<br>16. Barry***** for W514 of Buck Weaver!!<br>17. ?<br>18. JDRUM**** Neilson's Wally Schang, the shiny front one<br>19. JDRUM**** V100 Harry Hooper good eye<br>20. JDRUM**** 1933 World Wide Gum Jack Quinn<br>21. JDRUM**** 1934 World Wide Gum Chuck Klein
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:21 PM
Posted By: <b>Bob Manning</b><p>13! W512 Ty Cobb
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:23 PM
Posted By: <b>Frank Wakefield</b><p>Bob, you have that card-radar warmed up, now...<br><br><br>1. MIchael***** R3221936 Goudey Rick Ferrell<br>2. JDRUM**** WG4/5 GC Alexander<br>3. JDRUM**** E120 Walter Mails bidding on this card is how I got my eBay name, and the name here...<br>4. JDRUM**** E120 Austin McHenry an interesting player<br>5. JDRUM**** E126 Aaron Ward<br>6. JDRUM* Helmar Stamp, YES, but who????<br>7. JDRUM** T213 Coupon Ira Thomas<br>8. JDRUM**** W574 Bill Sillinger<br>9. JDRUM**** 1933 DelOng Jimmy Foxx<br>10. JDRUM**** E121 Heilmann<br>11. ?<br>12. Michael**** E90-1 Karger, a tough card -1* for JDRUM<br>13. Bob******* W512 Ty Cobb, a ballplayer<br>14. ?<br>15. ?<br>16. Barry***** for W514 of Buck Weaver!!<br>17. ?<br>18. JDRUM**** Neilson's Wally Schang, the shiny front one<br>19. JDRUM**** V100 Harry Hooper good eye<br>20. JDRUM**** 1933 World Wide Gum Jack Quinn<br>21. JDRUM**** 1934 World Wide Gum Chuck Klein<br><br>
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:35 PM
Posted By: <b>Bob Manning</b><p>14. W513 Lloyd Waner Little Poison
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:36 PM
Posted By: <b>barrysloate</b><p>#17 is W551 Dave Bancroft.
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:38 PM
Posted By: <b>Rhett Yeakley</b><p>Frank, this looked like a fun one, I'm late tot he game. I think these are the only 2 left<br><br>#11 is E135 Collins-McCarthy Bill Fischer (or possibly one of the related sets like Boston Store, etc.<br><br>#15 is a W515-1 card, can't tell who though<br><br>-Rhett
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:39 PM
Posted By: <b>Brian C.</b><p>...Ed Reulbach.
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:40 PM
Posted By: <b>JDRUM</b><p>Is it Jess Barnes?
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:40 PM
Posted By: <b>Rhett Yeakley</b><p>#15 is Hugh McQuillen<br>-Rhett
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:44 PM
Posted By: <b>Frank Wakefield</b><p>OK, guys.....<br><br>only lacking the player ID on #6 and #15, you guys have the card types correct....<br><br><br>1. MIchael***** R3221936 Goudey Rick Ferrell<br>2. JDRUM**** WG4/5 GC Alexander<br>3. JDRUM**** E120 Walter Mails bidding on this card is how I got my eBay name, and the name here...<br>4. JDRUM**** E120 Austin McHenry an interesting player<br>5. JDRUM**** E126 Aaron Ward<br>6. JDRUM* Helmar Stamp, YES, but who????<br>7. JDRUM** T213 Coupon Ira Thomas<br>8. JDRUM**** W574 Bill Sillinger<br>9. JDRUM**** 1933 DelOng Jimmy Foxx<br>10. JDRUM**** E121 Heilmann<br>11. Rhett******* E135 Collins McCarthy, right you are, Rhett Bill Fischer of the Pirates<br>12. Michael**** E90-1 Karger, a tough card -1* for JDRUM<br>13. Bob******* W512 Ty Cobb, a ballplayer<br>14. Bob******** W513 Lloyd Waner<br>15. Rhett* W515, but who???<br>16. Barry***** for W514 of Buck Weaver!!<br>17. Barry******* W551 Hall of Famer Dave Bancroft<br>18. JDRUM**** Neilson's Wally Schang, the shiny front one<br>19. JDRUM**** V100 Harry Hooper good eye<br>20. JDRUM**** 1933 World Wide Gum Jack Quinn<br>21. JDRUM**** 1934 World Wide Gum Chuck Klein<br>
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:46 PM
Posted By: <b>Rhett Yeakley</b><p>Frank, I think Brian Campf is right with Reulbach, and #15 is McQuillen<br>-Rhett
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:47 PM
Posted By: <b>Frank Wakefield</b><p>YOU GUYS got 'em!!!! Got them all!!!<br><br>1. MIchael***** R3221936 Goudey Rick Ferrell<br>2. JDRUM**** WG4/5 GC Alexander<br>3. JDRUM**** E120 Walter Mails bidding on this card is how I got my eBay name, and the name here...<br>4. JDRUM**** E120 Austin McHenry an interesting player<br>5. JDRUM**** E126 Aaron Ward<br>6. JDRUM* Helmar Stamp, YES, BrianC******* for Ed Reulbach<br>7. JDRUM** T213 Coupon Ira Thomas<br>8. JDRUM**** W574 Bill Sillinger<br>9. JDRUM**** 1933 DelOng Jimmy Foxx<br>10. JDRUM**** E121 Heilmann<br>11. Rhett******* E135 Collins McCarthy, right you are, Rhett Bill Fischer of the Pirates<br>12. Michael**** E90-1 Karger, a tough card -1* for JDRUM<br>13. Bob******* W512 Ty Cobb, a ballplayer<br>14. Bob******** W513 Lloyd Waner<br>15. Rhett****** W515, Hugh McQuillen<br>16. Barry***** for W514 of Buck Weaver!!<br>17. Barry******* W551 Hall of Famer Dave Bancroft<br>18. JDRUM**** Neilson's Wally Schang, the shiny front one<br>19. JDRUM**** V100 Harry Hooper good eye<br>20. JDRUM**** 1933 World Wide Gum Jack Quinn<br>21. JDRUM**** 1934 World Wide Gum Chuck Klein<br><br>
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:48 PM
Posted By: <b>Frank Wakefield</b><p>Right, Rhett... you guys are posting while I'm trying to post and type. I'm an old, slow &quot;typer&quot;.<br>
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:50 PM
Posted By: <b>Rhett Yeakley</b><p>Frank, I just took a closer look at the cards &amp; the W574 is Bill Killefer, not Sillinger.<br>-Rhett
Archive
03-14-2009, 06:54 PM
Posted By: <b>Bob Manning</b><p>Anybody know why Bill Killefer was called &quot;Reindeer?&quot;
Archive
03-14-2009, 07:17 PM
Posted By: <b>Frank Wakefield</b><p>Killefer is correct... he ran with great speed, catching up to baseballs making him dear to his pitchers.<br><br>Caption on his Sporting News card is &quot;Wm. Killefer, Jr.&quot;<br><br>Good eye, Rhett.
Archive
03-15-2009, 12:05 PM
Posted By: <b>Bob Manning</b><p>In fact Reindeer Bill was a catcher, and a pretty good one too. At least his friend GC Alexander thought so. When, in 1917, the Phils needed money, at Ol' Pete's request they were both traded to the Cubs, for Pickles Dillhoefer, Mike Prendergast and $55,000.<br><br>After has playing days he managed the Cubs and Browns for a total of nine years, never finishing higher than 4th. As a scout for Bill Veeck, he was instrumental in signing Larry Doby to an Indians contract, helping to break the color barrier in the AL.<br>