set collectors [Archive] - Net54baseball.com Forums

Archive

05-31-2007, 06:34 AM

Posted By: Steve Murray1906 Sporting Life Postcard Set. Have 15/16. Need Detroit to complete. 1906 Ullman Postcard Set. Need 3 of 12 to complete. 1911 Zeenut Set. Need 9 of 122 to complete. Maggert Zeenut run. Need 1915 to complete. e100 San Francisco sub-set. Need Weaver to complete. Zeenut run 1911 to 1938. Need 1938 to complete.

Archive

05-31-2007, 08:23 AM

Posted By: Anthony'15 CJ- need 1 (Jackson, of course) E91 A/B/C NL Fan Craze '33 Sport Kings Tango Eggs- can't even figure out if I need 9,10, or 11 more '41 Goudey still need half of the 132 cards (all colors) '52 Coke Tips- Thompson Hitting '54 Dan Dee- need 1 '58 Hires Test- need 4 with tabs '60 Fleer- 2 of the #80's Nickel packs of '52, '56 and '58 Topps plus the continual upgrades of other sets- T200, '36 Goudey, '41 Playball, '49 Leaf, T218, '58 Bell Brand.

Archive

05-31-2007, 08:30 AM

Posted By: Brian1909 Obak (80% finished) 1911 Obak (75% finished)

Archive

05-31-2007, 08:30 AM

Posted By: T206CollectorTee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks--Tee--Too--Oh--Siks-- ... (I could keep going, cuz I really am)

Archive

05-31-2007, 08:49 AM

Posted By: Kenneth A. CohenE96 E120 (probably next to impossible) 33 Goudey Tattoo Orbit

Archive

05-31-2007, 08:58 AM

Posted By: Ray PiskadloT206. 4 years into my 10 year goal, 200/520. T200. 2 years into my 5 year goal, 6/16. T209-1. 6 months into my 5 year goal, 2/16. 1914 CJ. 2 months into my goal of 1 per month, 2/144.

Archive

05-31-2007, 09:00 AM

Posted By: dstudebae222 e100 e99 Any help is always appreciated!

Archive

05-31-2007, 09:04 AM

Posted By: John HarrellT205, U.S. Caramel, George C.Miller, Sport Kings, 33 WWG back variations, R312, 1937 O-Pee-Chee, 1936 Maranville folders, Double play, 1941 Goudey basic set. John

Archive

05-31-2007, 09:37 AM

Posted By: Josh AdamsI'm working on the 1933 Goudey set (6 to go), and the e93 set (19 to go). Go Go White Sox 2005 World Series Champions!

Archive

05-31-2007, 09:51 AM

Posted By: steveSlight deviation if I may - I noticed most of net54'ers seem to, indeed, be set collectors. However, I am curious how many folks are non-set collectors, like me ? The vintage material is so nice. I have a collection of no more than 40 cards - all in PSA or SGC - all major HOF'ers - all in EX 5 or better. No sets, just a great sampling of Matty's, Cobb's, W.Johnson's, Young's and a couple Wagner's. I just can't get into the commons just to make sets. I realize building sets is a hobby mainstay, but to toss money after a bunch of commons - I would rather have the one nice Matty. Thoughts ? Steve

Archive

05-31-2007, 10:01 AM

Posted By: Jason Lit's more a function of quantity over quality, and then of course, a favorite team, and a smaller budget. I have been able to purchase about 30 cards in the PSA 3 or 4 range for the same money as one of the cards you mention. Just a preference to be more active...but who knows, my tastes change all the time, so I may go your route some day... I might add, that your more focused collecting is certainly more desirable from a storage standpoint...and I would of course, like to be able to afford that grade of card...but until then, I have narrowed my focus to Cubs team sets. How do you choose what to go after (other than the 5 and above criteria)? a certain tier of HOFer? a team? Edited to include: To address your commons question, my thought/hope is that if you focus your collection (like a team set), then perhaps there is the chance that someday the value of the group will be higher, since the commons are included. This of course, depends on 1)how difficult the commons are to acquire, and 2)how desirable/popular your focused collection/set actually is to the buying public...this could be flawed thinking, and perhaps you could always clear a better price as singles on Ebay, but maybe in some instances, there could be added value...?

Archive

05-31-2007, 10:02 AM

Posted By: Jeffrey LichtmanSteve, I agree with you - though I still have a few sets filled with expensive commons, I have broken up at least one of mine in order to buy cards I actually carea bout. After selling 10 hard to get commons from my 1958 Topps set, I was able to buy a 1914 CJ Jackson in SGC 60. I'll take that trade anyday.

Archive

05-31-2007, 10:12 AM

Posted By: Joe PelaezMy favorite beautiful beater T206 set, is just missing 9 cards of the known T206 checklist. My unplanned eye popping T206 set, just needs one more card from the known T206 checklist. The T205 set is complete, as far as all the front cards are concerned. Complete T201 set. Complete T209 Type 1 set. I have 219 different cards from the T209 Type II set. At 76, most of my collecting years are behind me, but I'm toying with the idea of going after the T210 set. What, am I crazy? Is there a Head doctor in the house?

Archive

05-31-2007, 10:17 AM

Posted By: BobD311 Pacific Coast Biscuit, E94 master set, 1911 Zeenut (close), 1912 Zeenut (long way to go). I am afraid that the PCL sets are going to be a life-long endeavors <img src="/images/sad.gif" height=14 width=14>

Archive

05-31-2007, 10:26 AM

Posted By: steveJason, I am no big spender - the "big" auctions are out of my league. I focus on ebay and look for anything that intrigues me, within my reasonable budget of up to $2k. per card. But I may only make a 2-4 purchases a year, after a decade plus, there you go, 40 vintage beauties (to me). When I need to satisfy my card urge on a small budget - well, thank goodness for quality Walter Payton's - just loved "sweetness." Steve.

Archive

05-31-2007, 10:29 AM

Posted By: Joe D.I don't particularly consider myself a set collector for the very reasons you mention - its hard for me to go after cards I would otherwise have no interest in. Now for me, the T200s are the exception to the rule..... I think that is the non-set-collectors set to collect. Only 16 cards, and a HOFer or otherwise collectible player in just about every one.

Archive

05-31-2007, 10:35 AM

Posted By: Jason LI forgot about our shared interest in cards of the great WP! Do you stick to tobacco issues, with that kind of focused collection? or is anything fair game? - whatever strikes you at the time? Did you used to collect sets and just got sick of it? edited for spellllllllling

Archive

05-31-2007, 10:38 AM

Posted By: barry arnoldT206 I now have 503 different T206s out of my magic number of 517 (524 minus Cobb with Cobb back which i don't see as T206 and the Big expensive 6). all the best, barry

Archive

05-31-2007, 10:40 AM

Posted By: E, DanielI can't do the set thing either...... Love type cards though! Some boxing and other sport types.....sorry for the flash. <img src="http://www.network54.com/Realm/tmp/1180543148.JPG"> Daniel

Archive

05-31-2007, 10:45 AM

Posted By: scott steve, i'm currently debating this very question now. i'm looking to rebuild my collection fron scratch after selling the last few cards 2 years ago.i'm on a limited budget so i'm debating buying only HOF's ,purchasing 3-5 cards a year or mix in some nicer "rare" commons such as those in some of the caramel sets.another option was starting to build a set...the reason i started this thread.my concern is the $$$ i use to buy a couple cheaper commons i could buy a nice "matty,cy or walter".i'm in no hurry to purchase so this is something i'll workout in time.

Archive

05-31-2007, 10:54 AM

Posted By: Al C.risafulli1938 Goudey - done, always upgrading 1939 Goudey R303 (sepia) - About 80% done 1936 R311 - About 60% done T205 - About 40% done W502 - About 33% done E95 - Just started; 2 cards in HOF Type Set - looking for at least one card of each prewar HOFer - ongoing 1973 Topps '53 Reprints - just need Al Rosen -Al

Archive

05-31-2007, 10:55 AM

Posted By: steve yawitzI'm about halfway into the Monster and plan on sticking with it. I'm a little over halfway into the E93 set, but have hit a lull. My restlessness led me to list my Wagner on 20-cent day; if it sells, I'll probably dump most of the rest of my Standard Caramels. That's a pretty typical pattern for me, actually. Building sets always sounds great, but I get too antsy and always end up finding something else I'd rather have.

Archive

05-31-2007, 11:01 AM

Posted By: peter chaoScott, Steve I've completed the '57 Topps set and presently 10 cards into the 1933 Goudey set. But I don't consider myself a set builder, most of the time I simply try to buy key cards in key sets. For the most part that means HOFs but not necessarily. My motto is it's your money spend it the way you want. Peter

Archive

05-31-2007, 11:02 AM

Posted By: Scott T1909-11 T206 (extremely low grade) 94% complete Scott

Archive

05-31-2007, 11:04 AM

Posted By: steveJason and Others, I frequently sell to then trade up with perhaps added cash. Pick-up examples last couple years: T206 Cobb green PSA 5 S74 silk Matty GAI 7 S74 silk W.Johnson GAI 6 PX7 domino disc Matty PSA 7 PX7 domino disc W.Johnson PSA 6 Colgan's Chip, H.Wagner PSA 8 T202 Cobb/Cobb steals 3rd PSA 5 1922 w575 W.Johnson SGC 86 1926 spalding W.Johnson PSA 9 1948 leaf T.Williams PSA 7 1949 bowman Paige PSA 6 Some rare items in the bunch, not too over-the-top spendy. Steve

Archive

05-31-2007, 11:23 AM

Posted By: Alan O'ConnorMy narrow slice of this hobby is Sacramento baseball. My attempt at sets include: 1911 Big Eater Have none. 0% complete 1928 PCL Exhibits (W465)Sac Have 1 of 5. 20% complete 1940 Hughes Frozen Confections (F66) Have 14 of 20 70% complete (I also collect Sac T212, T4, D311, D310, E99, E100, T217, E136, E137, UO11 & F65, but the computations are too taxing this morning!) Patience is a virtue! Alan

Archive

05-31-2007, 11:59 AM

Posted By: S GrossBaseball: T207 -- just passed 50% mark, slow and steady ........ Boxing: 1921 Exhibits -- Complete 58/58 T9 Turkey Red -- 20/26 -- Been stuck for quite awhile. E77 American Caramel -- 15/24 -- Haven't seen one in so long I almost forget what they look like. <img src="/images/happy.gif" height=14 width=14> T225 Khedivial Series 2 -- 14/25 -- Series 2 is so much much more rare than Series 1. Just glad to add one every so often. Battling Nelson Type Cards -- 22 of a theoretical 36 -- there are some T225 back combinations I'm not sure exist, and some issues (Pet, Kopac, Red Cross) that probably ain't gonna' happen. Boxing strips, various issues -- 115/?????????? who knows !!!!

Archive

05-31-2007, 12:04 PM

Posted By: Joe Pelaez"T206 I now have 503 different T206s out of my magic number of 517 (524 minus Cobb with Cobb back which i don't see as T206 and the Big expensive 6)." * * Congratulations. I've been following your T206 Quest, and you're doing great. I would like to make a slight suggestion, if I may. Take it from someone raised in Spanish Harlem during the '30's and '40's. As a 10 year old in 1941, I would buy packs of gum from a candy store, with 1941 Play Ball cards inside. Then I would flip them with other kids from my grade school near by. Barry, in those days, I didn't know who Wagner or Cobb was. In fact, I didn't know tobacco cards existed. I got back into cards in 1982, and I started with collecting rookie cards. ... WRONG direction. Wrong direction, because it was part of the investor/market/capitalization/stock market mind set. That's not what I wanted. ... I already had a job, and I wanted a sublimation from it. I decided to collect for the fun, and enjoyment of it. Not ever thinking of what the card would fetch later. It was a choice that I never regretted. I kept my collecting hobby as a hobby, and not a portfolio. As one collector to another. Raise the bar just a wee bit. Get rid of the 517 number Back in 1941, I didn't know that I would own two almost complete T206 sets, and I agree with what you said about the Cobb back. Raise the bar, and like that famous old ball player once said: "ONENEVERKNOWS." BTW, who did what to this thread? I now need two plasma screens, side by side, in order to read it. <img src="/images/happy.gif" height=14 width=14> Joe P.

Archive

05-31-2007, 12:21 PM

Posted By: Joe PelaezI notice that you collect T217 Mono's. Do you have any doubles for trade? I have 20/25, with some doubles for trade. Joe P.

Archive

05-31-2007, 12:28 PM

Posted By: Jason Lnice list there! - very diverse breadth Which Cy Young caught your eye for the collection? Any Lajoie? I know I missed out on your T206(w/bat) sale a couple months back! <img src="/images/sad.gif" height=14 width=14> -I like your term "spendy" - can I use that?

Archive

05-31-2007, 12:43 PM

Posted By: Peter ThomasCompleted sets still trying to upgrade T204 with square borders T209-1 E-93 E-103 33 Delong 49 Leaf Working on: T205 T212 1909, 1910, 1911 E90-1 E92 master set E94 E95 E96 E97 E98 HR Kisses 1911 Zeenut 1912 Zeenut 1931 Zeenut 1932 Zeenut

Archive

05-31-2007, 12:49 PM

Posted By: steveIn Cy Young I have a PX7 domino disc PSA 4, T206 portrait PSA 5, and T206 glove shows PSA 5. In Lajoie, I just sold the T206 w/bat PSA 5, still have T206 throwing SGC 60.

Archive

05-31-2007, 12:50 PM

Posted By: Ken McMillancomplete set of topps cubs 1951 to current including updates, errors and variations. Set is actually complete to my knowledge. Waiting for series 2 topps for this year. All else is done. Ken

Archive

05-31-2007, 01:08 PM

Posted By: Bruce MacPhersonCompleted: E90-2 E93 E98 Better than half way on the following: E90-3 E94 E97 E102 E104-1 1914/15 Cracker Jack (HOFers only) Somehow I keep getting sidetracked by picking up type cards.

Archive

05-31-2007, 01:12 PM

Posted By: Dan BrettaThis thread would be a lot easier to read if Paul (T206 Collector) would edit his post to put some breaks in his "tee-too-oh-six.......line).

Archive

05-31-2007, 01:27 PM

Posted By: Pennsylvania TedSince 1977 I have completed the following sets....... N28 N162 (2 sets) N284 (Buchner....74 cards) T205 (209 cards) T206 (set #1....521 cards) T206 (set #2....520 cards) T206 (set #3....518 all-PIEDMONT cards) T206 (set #4....370 of 404 all-SOVEREIGN cards) T207 E90-1 (120 cards) 1933 Goudey (set #1....239 cards) 1933 Goudey (set #2....237 cards) 1934 Goudey 1936 Goudey 1941 Goudey 1934-36 Batter-Up 1934-36 Diamond Stars (110 cards) 1936 R312 1939 Play Ball 1940 Play Ball 1941 Play Ball (2 sets) 1947 Homogenized Bond Bread 1948 Leaf Boxing (2 sets) 1948 Bowman (BB and FB sets) 1949 Leaf BB (101 cards) 1949 Bowman (if I was to say how many, no one would believe me....so I wont) 1949 Bowman PCL (2 sets) 1950 Bowman (324 cards) 1951 Bowman (325 cards) 1952 to 1955 Bowman BB and FB sets 1952 Topps (512 cards) 1953 to 1985 Topps 1959 Fleer (2 sets) There's more....but I wont bore....you.

Archive

05-31-2007, 01:42 PM

Posted By: Jason Lquite an effort to be proud of... but you forgot to list your 1949 Bowman PCL!!!

Archive

05-31-2007, 02:28 PM

Posted By: Pennsylvania TedThank you, guy.....I can't believe I forgot the PCL set....too many to remember.

Archive

05-31-2007, 07:21 PM

Posted By: DMcDFinished a player set of D304s last year. Trying to complete a T3 set (91/100). Also collecting WWG Ice Kings (12/72). Am going to cool my jets on set collecting after that and focus on cherrypicking single cards I like for whatever reason. <img src="http://www.network54.com/Realm/May07/IK_Horner.JPG"> Some sets I've collected: (Note no T206 or 52 Topps sets; I am scared of monsters) ('50 Bowman set in white binder-from year I was born; it's a humdinger. Also have '50 Bowman FB set) <img src="http://www.network54.com/Realm/May07/Sets.JPG"> My contribution to The Hobby: <img src="http://www.network54.com/Realm/May07/Scrooge1.jpg">

Archive

05-31-2007, 07:40 PM

Posted By: judson hamlinworking on: Diamond Stars (89), E90 (63), E92/101/102 (as one set) (29), E95 (18), E96 (12), 1933 Goudey (209), '34 (48), '36 (done), 1939 Playball (130), '40 (230), '41 (done), T201 (40), T205 (120), T209 and T210 Richmond, Va (19), T222 (15), Tattoo Orbit (16) and T206 (509). Focus is not necessarily my strong suit.

Archive

05-31-2007, 09:35 PM

Posted By: AnonymousWorking on E95, and a type set consisting of all the various T and E cards(including various brands for each issue) that were produced in color.

Archive

06-01-2007, 12:26 AM

Posted By: barry arnoldJoe P. Many,many thanks for the kind words and sage advice. I have made myself singleminded about the T206 Grail and have found that parameters provide some comfort,e.g. the 517 figure. This is probably the practical,professorial part of me. The young little leaguer and pony leaguer part of me still knows as you so aptly put it---OneNeverKnows. And this dreaming, imagining part of me is what makes me look at those beautiful auction catalogues again and again, taking an extra long look at the Plank or the Magie. Thanks much for revivifying the imaginings tonight, Joe. They're always around-- just sometimes governed a wee bit too much. No governor around tonight, at 1:25am. <img src="/images/happy.gif" height=14 width=14> all the best, barry

Archive

06-01-2007, 09:15 AM

Posted By: Joe PelaezDon Quijote's fight against the imaginary windmills, had a greater feel when he would be surprised by an unexpected victory. <img src="/images/wink.gif" height=14 width=14> All the best in your Quest. Joe

Archive

06-01-2007, 05:48 PM

Posted By: GlennE95, Diamond Stars, and C46, but at my current pace I won't be finishing any of them in the next 10 years.

Archive

06-01-2007, 06:09 PM

Posted By: Dave HornishTrying to do the T206-6. Figure it will take 7 years.

Archive

06-02-2007, 09:56 AM

Posted By: Brian McQueen I've started a few sets...one for each major "genre" of the 20th century - e99 -- 6 out of 30 d322 -- 18 out of 25 c46 -- 68 out of 90 m116 (bluebacks) -- 23 out of 24 (but only if you count proofs and advertisement pieces <img src="/images/happy.gif" height=14 width=14> ) I also collect other various type cards from the 20th century sets. It's more or less just me identifying my favorite cards from specific sets and going after those only.

Archive

06-02-2007, 10:54 AM

Posted By: Jason LWhat do you mean by genre? like: tobacco, caramel, bakery, candy, gum, etc?

Archive

06-02-2007, 11:06 AM

Posted By: Chris Mc 1939 Playball 1947 Sports Exchange W602 1948 Bowman 1929 Rogers Peet 1976 Topps 1976 Topps traded 1887 Old Judge Browns Champions When I finish the Playball set in SGC(34 more)and the 48 Bowman I want to work on 49 Bowman and Old Judges.

Archive

06-02-2007, 11:11 AM

Posted By: Jason LThat's a neat & interesting variety of sets....how'd you pick 'em? the 1976, for instance?

Archive

06-02-2007, 02:33 PM

Posted By: Chris McHey Jason, Once upon a time I thought I was a type card collector but I am a set collector at heart. I like the black and white sets of the 20's-40'S. I love the OJ's but my budget dictates that I go for the Brown's subset before going after the monster set. The 76 Topps goes back to the first cards I collected as a 9 year old, so I have a soft spot for them only now they are in SGC holders instead of bike spokes. It's good to have a bunch of different sets to add to. Best regards, Chris

Archive

06-02-2007, 08:14 PM

Posted By: Andy CookCompleted and still own: T209 color T210-2 Completed and later broken up E90-2, E91-C, E92 Dockman, E93, E96, E106 (had 33 diff), several Goudey and Playball sets Working on T210 (all series other than 2) T211 (have 8) T212-2 (have half of set) T213-2 (need 11) C46 (have about half of set) Zeenuts - 1912 (half done), 1914 (half done), 1919 (half done), 1923 (40% done), 1931 (need 3) 1949 Bowman PCL (35% done) 1952 Mothers Cookie Would like to get more of these and work on these sets E100 (have 4), T217 (have 2), 1950 Hages Dairy, M116 Minor Leaguers I will trade aggressively for cards I need from the above sets. Andy

Archive

06-02-2007, 08:59 PM

Posted By: John HarrellSo far I've completed the following prewar: 1888 Gargling Oil Linament E91C 1932 Sanella margarine Delong 1933 Goudey 1933 World Wide Gum R305 Tattoo Orbit Diamond Stars master set (170 cards) 1934 Goudey 1934 World Wide Gum 1935 Goudey 1936 Goudey 1936 S&S game cards 1938 Goudey 1941 Play Ball 1943 & 49 M.P. & Co. Prewars working on: T205 U.S. Caramel George C. Miller Sport Kings Batter Up R312 Maranville Folders 1941 Goudey Postwar completed: 54, 56, 69 through 80 Topps 60,61-62,63, 70,71 Fleer 67 Laughlin Postwar working on: Connie Mack All Stars 52,53,55,57 through 68 Topps 48-55 Bowman 59 Fleer John

Archive

06-03-2007, 10:41 AM

Posted By: daryleFinished several of my favorites: 1888 N28 (50 cards) 1941 Play Ball 1952-1954 Topps 1956 Topps Working on: *1933 Goudey (need 8-10 commons and most of the HOFers, so need like 60-70 cards) *1923 W515-2 Little Wonder Picture Series; need 2....help!!! (wouldn't even be attempting if I hadn't bought a strip-card collection that included what I thought was a complete W515 set but after reading Lemke's column in SCD about some "odd" W515s that had been found with letters across the top I got my "set" out and wah-lah.......54 of the 60 cards either had the letters or were larger in size......so the search started.) *1955 Topps (love the '52-'56 Topps run) *1952 Topps Red/Black #1-80 *1953 Topps (white/black variations)