Help with Old Judge Variations [Archive] - Net54baseball.com Forums

View Full Version : Help with Old Judge Variations

Archive

06-13-2002, 12:35 PM

Posted By: James WHello, I'm new to collecting vintage (pre-war) cards and was wondering if someone here could help me. I'm interested in collecting all the Parke Swartzel Old Judge (N-172) cards. I've haven't been collecting cards for about the past 4-5 years and only have a Beckett Collectors guide. In that, it talks about some cards having no number and some with numbers, also some have copywrite dates while others don't. In all, it said there was something like 5k variations in the set. So my question is, what all known variations exist for Parke Swartzel? Thanks for the help, James Walker Jr.

Archive

06-13-2002, 02:05 PM

Posted By: Trevor HockingWell if I can recall correctly there should be 6 different poses of Swartzel. Now as far as variations well that's a different story. There are many kinds of variations in the N172 set, team, year, Old Judge ad, even color for the picky which is caused from the picture aging. The pink color can only be found on cards produced from 1889 or 1890 due to the change in the paper used for printing the photograph. (Obviously) If you don't mind me asking what's you intrest with Mr. Swartzel? Please feel free to e-mail me if you have any further questions and welcome to the 19th century world. Trevor Hocking trevor@dlhstudios.com

Archive

06-14-2002, 11:05 AM

Posted By: Bob LemkeAccording to the World Tobacco Index which we have run in the Standard Catalog in the past, and may again someday, Swartzel is found in six poses: 1) batting, 2) fielding, 3) pitching, hands by left shoulder, 4) pitching, ball in right hand, thigh-high, 5) pitching, right hand by head and 6) in jacket, arms at sides. If you want to consider typographic variations, #1 can be found either with, or without a comma after the P and #2 can be found as Kansas City or Kansas Citys. This should be a lifelong challenge for you -- Good Luck!

Archive

06-14-2002, 11:26 AM

Posted By: john(z28jd)good luck trying to find all the variations of a certain player for sale,ive been at it for 4 years collecting the same player and im still missing 2 variations which ive never even seen,but it will be cool when you do find the ones youre looking for..... good luck and it would be intersting to hear(as trevor already asked) why this particular player?

Archive

06-15-2002, 07:47 AM

Posted By: James WThe reason I'm trying to collect this player is as follows. I've live in central Indiana and have always wondered if someone from my home town has ever played pro-basbeball. Well, a few days back I was visiting www.baseball-reference.com and noticed they have birth places listed. To my surprise, there was one person who played and was from my home town. However, he was never on any cards. So, Parke Swartzel was the closest person born to my home town. Also, my father was raised in the same town that Parke was born. That's why I'm trying to collect Parke. Along with Parke, I'm also starting a T206 collection. James Walker, Jr.

Archive

06-15-2002, 09:21 AM

Posted By: Jay MillerJames--I have one Swartzel Old judge available. If interested, please email me at curl777@aol.com and I will send a scan and quote a price. Best---Jay