Allegheny Card Co. [Archive] - Net54baseball.com Forums

Archive

01-14-2002, 06:16 AM

Posted By: Jaime LeidermanCan someone post more info. on this set? SCBC prices are pretty high and the one on eBay is the first one I've seen so far. JL

Archive

01-14-2002, 07:43 AM

Posted By: leonIt is a McGinnity. I understand there is one set of these (as already discussed). The set has made the rounds after being broken up. I believe Bill Mastro had it then it changed hands a few times and Kevin Struss had some of them. I got mine from Terry Knouse who had quite a few of them. Kevin told me that he considers them all proofs and they were hand cut. Nice pictures and a nice looking back. Very nice set for type collectors like myself. Sorry I don't have more concrete info.....this set has been discussed on this or the Fullcount board before but I don't remember all of the specifics....regards

Archive

01-14-2002, 08:50 AM

Posted By: Kevin CummingsI believe Leon is correct when he says these have "made the rounds." I, too, have one (Duff Cooley) which I got from SportscardsPlus (who, I believe, got them from Lew Lipset) almost two years ago for considerably less than the one currentlly being offered on eBay by Terry Knouse. Most of whatever is common knowledge today about the set is conjecture. People assume it was going to be a card game of some sort because of the design, but with no markings other than the player/team/league stuff on the card, I'm not sure what you could have played. The cards are also on fairly thin stock (more like Walter Mails than the later playing cards like Fan Craze, Polo Grounds, Tom Barker) and no one knows if this was going to be the "production" style or just a mock up to be produced later on heavier stock. It is also odd that only the National League is represented, again leading to speculation that a parallel American League version might later have been developed had this one proved successful. Like the Breisch Williams, because of the timing there were players available in this set not to be found anywhere else.

Archive

01-14-2002, 02:22 PM

Posted By: Julie VognarI bought my Kid Gleason for 499, and then a few months later. Sports Cards Plus called me and said they were reducing the price by 100 dollars--but there weren't any others i wanted. They are DEFINITELY hand cut--and the less important the player (at the time), the more carelessly they are cut. Kid Gleason was a nobody, who'd not yet told Cicotte to put soap on his ball, or Weaver to try batting from both sides of the plate, so it's somewhat uneven. The Wagner, the Tinker etc. which I'ver seen pictures of, are much more carefully c cut. And now, over a year later SCD guide 2002 says the commons should go for $900. Go figure. It is nice to have a one-of-akind card, though. Julie <img src="/images/happy.gif" height=14 width=14>

Archive

01-14-2002, 02:22 PM

Posted By: Julie VognarI bought my Kid Gleason for 499, and then a few months later. Sports Cards Plus called me and said they were reducing the price by 100 dollars--but there weren't any others i wanted. They are DEFINITELY hand cut--and the less important the player (at the time), the more carelessly they are cut. Kid Gleason was a nobody, who'd not yet told Cicotte to put soap on his ball, or Weaver to try batting from both sides of the plate, so it's somewhat uneven. The Wagner, the Tinker etc. which I'ver seen pictures of, are much more carefully c cut. And now, over a year later SCD guide 2002 says the commons should go for $900. Go figure. It is nice to have a one-of-akind card, though. Julie <img src="/images/happy.gif" height=14 width=14>

Archive

01-14-2002, 02:35 PM

Posted By: Andy BaranI bought the Mordecai Brown card from Terry a few months ago. I bought it because Brown is not in the E107 Breisch Williams set, so I consider this to be his Rookie Card, and it's the only one in existance (like the Just So Jesse Burkett that I wish I owned). To the best of my knowledge, it is also the only Brown card that lists him with St. Louis. <img src="http://www.network54.com/Realm/tmp/1011047578.JPG">

Archive

01-14-2002, 04:28 PM

Posted By: HalleyGatorSorry Andy, you got ripped. That's not Three Fingers Brown ... it's his predecessor, Two Fingers Brown. You were SO close. <img src="/images/happy.gif" height=14 width=14>

Archive

01-14-2002, 05:12 PM

Posted By: Scott Forrest...

Archive

01-14-2002, 08:49 PM

Posted By: Brian HodesThe one I am most interested in is Manager Frank Selee -- I checked and Terry K. didn't have it. Although it may be rather expensive (it's his only card that I am aware of) I would be interested in knowing who has it in case they ever decide to move it. I think I asked the old (full-count) board about this before ... Does anyone out there know who owns that card?