These two cards actually the same card?

[tbr5020]

Hi Guys,

Is the card on EBay legitimate? Thoughts?

Thanks!

https://www.ebay.com/itm/1909-T206-George-Davis-120-White-Borders-PSA-7/373373296991?hash=item56eec8615f:g:SogAAOSwa6Jfxhc h

https://memorylaneinc.com/site/bids/bidplace?itemid=21651

[DanP]

It’s the same card, but the Memory Lane auction ended in Oct.

It looks legitimate to me.

[philo98]

It’s the same card, but the Memory Lane auction ended in Oct.

It looks legitimate to me.

Looks like an auction in 2011.

[swarmee]

They look like the same card. I think there is an optical illusion going on making it look like the centering is different. But they both have the same slight registration, left border gap, and bottom border print mark. So I would say they're the same card. Looks like there is some staining on the back based on soaking that would be interesting to compare against, but the 2011 auction listing doesn't seem to have a back scan.

[Leon]

They look like the same card. I think there is an optical illusion going on making it look like the centering is different. But they both have the same slight registration, left border gap, and bottom border print mark. So I would say they're the same card. Looks like there is some staining on the back based on soaking that would be interesting to compare against, but the 2011 auction listing doesn't seem to have a back scan.

+1

[FrankWakefield]

"Looks like there is some staining on the back based on soaking"

I don't understand... are you saying that soaking caused the stains on the back? That looks like slight tobacco stains to me.

[swarmee]

Possibly. Look at the areas below the Q and Y in quality on the back. The blue lines look like it bled there, or it could be an illusion based on the scan.