Nice T204 Hartzell

[Leon]

This is a 2? Yikes....

https://www.ebay.com/itm/1909-T204-Ramly-Roy-Hartzell-Browns-PSA-2-GOOD/401743717979?hash=item5d89caa65b:m:mVK3CTr5tSCyiLP AQh1oXMw:sc:USPSFirstClass!75002!US!-1

.

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Makes you wonder if that's something that appeared after grading?

[Leon]

Makes you wonder if that's something that appeared after grading?

With grading nothing surprises me anymore. Maybe they thought since it doesn't have creases it should be good? At least give it an ST .....:cool:

[Corporal Lance Boil]

As someone who collects Ramlys, albeit slowly, I have really struggled with some of the grading that goes on, most notably the 3-4 range, although 2-5 seems to lack strict criteria as well.

I have 2's that look identical to 4's, and vice versa. The highest grade I own is a 6 and for the love of me it looks just like some 5's I have.

Although this obviously isn't the case here, I think the scarcity probably makes it difficult for graders to have seen enough of them to get a good feel.

I can't imagine that graded a "2". That must've grown afterwards. Right?

[perezfan]

I'm guessing Dean's won't be issuing that one a sticker.

Perhaps they could consign it through PWCC? :rolleyes:

[brianp-beme]

This is a 2? Yikes....

I consider this a PSA 5...the card does have an Excellent stain.

Brian

[Eric72]

Will PSA allow a grade without qualifiers when there is a stain on the card?