View Full Version : Something fishy about this 56 Mays
sickmantz
02-04-2018, 06:38 PM
https://www.ebay.com/itm/152893396197?ul_noapp=true
That can't possible be the card that was originally in that holder, can it?
swarmee
02-04-2018, 07:39 PM
Possible? Yes, it is posssible. Is your only worry about the centering top-to-bottom? The angle of photo makes it hard to gauge the centering, but it seems to be outside the PSA 7 guideline.
Photo angle make it hard to see frosting as well.
Jenx34
02-05-2018, 08:41 AM
Possible? Yes, it is posssible. Is your only worry about the centering top-to-bottom? The angle of photo makes it hard to gauge the centering, but it seems to be outside the PSA 7 guideline.
Photo angle make it hard to see frosting as well.
Two corners on the right look awfully shaky for a 7 too.
That is a 5 card in a 7 slab ....
I wish these sellers would realize they are turning off buyers and likely losing sales by using these cel phone photos that resemble the opening credits for Star Wars rather than a standard scan.
sickmantz
02-07-2018, 10:14 PM
In order for that centering to qualify for an overall grade of 7, it would have to be 9OC. That card is not a 9 in any way. It looks like a 5 with poor eye appeal to me. Makes me think it's a phony slab.