Brooklyn Dodgers photo John Rogers LOA

[JoeyFarino]

Just bought this 1952 Brooklyn Dodgers Type 1 and it comes with this LOA which Ive never seen before. I know the situation about Rogers but has anyone seen these LOA's like this

http://i450.photobucket.com/albums/qq224/Blackitalian/20170508_100317_zpsxrshpjng.png (http://s450.photobucket.com/user/Blackitalian/media/20170508_100317_zpsxrshpjng.png.html)

http://i450.photobucket.com/albums/qq224/Blackitalian/20170508_100413_zpsrrsbk9qr.png (http://s450.photobucket.com/user/Blackitalian/media/20170508_100413_zpsrrsbk9qr.png.html)

[bobfreedman]

Why the hell would you ask me what photos I have and then you ask to see images of them and then say I will buy one or two of them, then never hear from you again??? You are a piece of work Joey and I am very tired of your act. I wasted my time describing them to you, taking pictures of them for you, you agree to buy two of them, then one of them, and then you fall off the face of the earth? Buyer beware everyone, do not trust Joey.

[JoeyFarino]

Lol..Bob I was trying to do more research on a couple of the photos before I sent the money. Are u really butt hurt over $300???? Seriously??? And just because I didnt respond when you wanted me to you throw a tantrum and go on this crazy rant. I was looking into thos photos more since you lied and told me your 39 williams photo was a Type 1 when it clearly says wirephoto...smh

[bobfreedman]

Its not the money Joey, its respect for my time and getting back to me. Its called common courtesy so when you commit to someone and then you dont answer them, maybe you will learn your lesson

[JoeyFarino]

Bob you told me they were all Type 1's. One was a wirephoto and the other was a restrike so I didnt pull the trigger because it made me question the other ones

[slidekellyslide]

Did you happen to tell Bob any of that info before ceasing communication with him?

[JoeyFarino]

Did you happen to tell Bob any of that info before ceasing communication with him?

No I was waiting to hear back from a buddy about the others. I see his point but to ruin my thread over a private issue is something a little kid would do

[slidekellyslide]

No I was waiting to hear back from a buddy about the others. I see his point but to ruin my thread over a private issue is something a little kid would do

Well, if you're going to ignore his private communications what do you want him to do?

[JoeyFarino]

Well, if you're going to ignore his private communications what do you want him to do?

He sent me a text yesterday saying he wasnt going to sell me anything anymore. I didnt expect him to throw a tantrum

[JoeyFarino]

Well, if you're going to ignore his private communications what do you want him to do?

And I didnt expect bob to tell me his photos were all Type 1's when it was clearly marked wirephoto and the other robinson was a restrike

[slidekellyslide]

He sent me a text yesterday saying he wasnt going to sell me anything anymore. I didnt expect him to throw a tantrum

Well clearly you've made him mad. Perhaps you shouldn't have asked him for scans, told him you'd buy some of them and then ignored him. You don't think you owed him any explanation of why you had changed your mind?

[slidekellyslide]

And I didnt expect bob to tell me his photos were all Type 1's when it was clearly marked wirephoto and the other robinson was a restrike

So you didn't even think to tell him this is why you had decided not to buy the photos? Instead you ignored him.

[JoeyFarino]

Well clearly you've made him mad. Perhaps you shouldn't have asked him for scans, told him you'd buy some of them and then ignored him. You don't think you owed him any explanation of why you had changed your mind?

I texted him saturday and told him I'd get back to him. Clearly he's mad but didnt he was gonna turn into a diva

[slidekellyslide]

I texted him saturday and told him I'd get back to him. Clearly he's mad but didnt he was gonna turn into a diva

You'd be better served to not resort to ad-hominen attacks on Bob considering your past history here.

[JoeyFarino]

You'd be better served to not resort to ad-hominen attacks on Bob considering your past history here.

No disrespect but its honestly not your business. This is between me and Bob. If you were involved I'd understand. But Bob's a big boy. This isnt high school

[JoeyFarino]

Bob this couldve been us

http://i450.photobucket.com/albums/qq224/Blackitalian/john_c__reilly3_zpsoeiw5eso.jpg (http://s450.photobucket.com/user/Blackitalian/media/john_c__reilly3_zpsoeiw5eso.jpg.html)

[slidekellyslide]

No disrespect but its honestly not your business. This is between me and Bob. If you were involved I'd understand. But Bob's a big boy. This isnt high school

Ironically this wouldn't be an issue if you had acted honorably to begin with.

btw you don't get to decide what is and isn't my business on a forum that I moderate. Thanks.

[JoeyFarino]

Ironically this wouldn't be an issue if you had acted honorably to begin with.

btw you don't get to decide what is and isn't my business on a forum that I moderate. Thanks.


http://i450.photobucket.com/albums/qq224/Blackitalian/Wat8_zpsimhek70m.jpg (http://s450.photobucket.com/user/Blackitalian/media/Wat8_zpsimhek70m.jpg.html)

[RedsFan1941]

Didn't mean to post twice.

[RedsFan1941]

a guy gets called out for not honoring a deal and his answer is to post what he thinks are funny photos? Interesting.

[JoeyFarino]

How can it not a be moderator's business when a board member doesn't honor a deal, especially when that member has had issues on the board before?

Because it had NOTHING to do with him and he doesnt know the whole story. Bob is a big boy so we can deal with it not the whole f**kin forum

[JeremyW]

Big boys communicate with each other, promptly.

[slidekellyslide]

Because it had NOTHING to do with him and he doesnt know the whole story. Bob is a big boy so we can deal with it not the whole f**kin forum

Interesting. You had a problem with a guy and brought it to the board. Which didn't go well for you.

http://net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=169349&highlight=farino+bst

Your history in dealing with people in this hobby is shaky at best. Are you still banned from the BST? I had to chuckle the other day when you sent me a PM about my book that could have been posted in the thread you started, and then followed up with an inquiry to purchase it. I just figure now that most posts you start are your way of posting a wanted to buy ad and are not a genuine effort to learn and share.

[JoeyFarino]

Big boys communicate with each other, promptly.

Promptly huh??? So if you dont respond right away youre not a man??? interesting

[bobfreedman]

You can sling names all you want, the truth is That I don't want others to sell to you or think that they are selling to you any longer.

Also, you can tell the character of a person when something like this happens and instead of discussing it like an adult, you resort to name calling and sophomoric replies.

[JoeyFarino]

Interesting. You had a problem with a guy and brought it to the board. Which didn't go well for you.

http://net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=169349&highlight=farino+bst

Your history in dealing with people in this hobby is shaky at best. Are you still banned from the BST? I had to chuckle the other day when you sent me a PM about my book that could have been posted in the thread you started, and then followed up with an inquiry to purchase it. I just figure now that most posts you start are your way of posting a wanted to buy ad and are not a genuine effort to learn and share.

I did send you a PM about your book....And??? You responded back and never once said any of this or "chuckled". Are you Bob's translator? You must be real bored

[JoeyFarino]

You can sling names all you want, the truth is That I don't want others to sell to you or think that they are selling to you any longer.

Also, you can tell the character of a person when something like this happens and instead of discussing it like an adult, you resort to name calling and sophomoric replies.

Lol...Bob you literally showed me a 1939 ted williams photo that had "wirephoto" on the back and said it was a Type 1. You also showed me another photo that was a restrike claiming all were Type 1's which made be suspicious right away so wanted to further investigate the rest which were majority blank backs. Im questioning your intentions for lying to me

[slidekellyslide]

I did send you a PM about your book....And??? You responded back and never once said any of this or "chuckled". Are you Bob's translator? You must be real bored

I thought it was odd that you would PM me to ask me what year the book was written when that could have been asked on your thread. When you followed up with a query to buy it I chuckled because it was clear to me that your thread was just a disguised want ad. Now I'm not sure how you can know if I chuckled or not unless you have my house bugged.

[JoeyFarino]

And dont even try and say you didnt know. Youve handled and seen enough photos to know the difference. I told you saturday I'd get back to you and asked if you had any other photos. Sounds like you just wanted to be a diva and get everyone involved. Well played

[JoeyFarino]

I though it was odd that you would PM me to ask me what year the book was written when that could have been asked on your thread. When you followed up with a query to buy it I chuckled because it was clear to me that your thread was just a disguised want ad. Now I'm not sure how you can know if I chuckled or not unless you have my house bugged.

Wrong I saw something interesting and asked if you would consider selling it. Sooooooo your point is????

[slidekellyslide]

Wrong I saw something interesting and asked if you would consider selling it. Sooooooo your point is????

Are you still banned from the BST?

[JoeyFarino]

http://i450.photobucket.com/albums/qq224/Blackitalian/20170508_155134_zps9yht9ioz.png (http://s450.photobucket.com/user/Blackitalian/media/20170508_155134_zps9yht9ioz.png.html)

[bobfreedman]

I already told you that was my mistake when you texted me your F Bomb laced text message

[JoeyFarino]

I already told you that was my mistake when you texted me your F Bomb laced text message

ONLY when i called you out

[JoeyFarino]

I already told you that was my mistake when you texted me your F Bomb laced text message

You sent me numerous messages about it and not once did you say anything

[JoeyFarino]

Bob I wouldve gotten back to you eventually but was doing more research on the others because I simply didnt trust your word on them being Type 1's. It wasnt fast enough for you so you chose to be a diva and cry to everyone on the forum

[Runscott]

Just bought this 1952 Brooklyn Dodgers Type 1 and it comes with this LOA which Ive never seen before. I know the situation about Rogers but has anyone seen these LOA's like this

I have John Rogers LOA's like that - mine simply said that the photo came from a scrapbook belonging to a certain players' estate. I have had letters before that came from infamous hobbyists - you have to make the decision as to whether or not it is worth advertising when you attempt to sell or trade the piece. For instance, I used to have an item that was definitely authentic, right down to photo-matching; however, it once belonged to Barry Halper and had a letter from him, signed. The seller didn't mention this, but included it anyway. I thought it added an interesting parameter to the piece, as I had enough supporting evidence as to its authenticity.

Same thing for my Rogers letters - they indicate where the pieces came from, but really don't provide any other authentication. If Rogers claimed something was 'Type I' and I needed a letter, I would get someone else to look at it and then toss Rogers' letter.

[JoeyFarino]

I have John Rogers LOA's like that - mine simply said that the photo came from a scrapbook belonging to a certain players' estate. I have had letters before that came from infamous hobbyists - you have to make the decision as to whether or not it is worth advertising when you attempt to sell or trade the piece. For instance, I used to have an item that was definitely authentic, right down to photo-matching; however, it once belonged to Barry Halper and had a letter from him, signed. The seller didn't mention this, but included it anyway. I thought it added an interesting parameter to the piece, as I had enough supporting evidence as to its authenticity.

Same thing for my Rogers letters - they indicate where the pieces came from, but really don't provide any other authentication. If Rogers claimed something was 'Type I' and I needed a letter, I would get someone else to look at it and then toss Rogers' letter.

Thank you for the info. I appreciate it

[calvindog]

I have John Rogers LOA's like that - mine simply said that the photo came from a scrapbook belonging to a certain players' estate. I have had letters before that came from infamous hobbyists - you have to make the decision as to whether or not it is worth advertising when you attempt to sell or trade the piece. For instance, I used to have an item that was definitely authentic, right down to photo-matching; however, it once belonged to Barry Halper and had a letter from him, signed. The seller didn't mention this, but included it anyway. I thought it added an interesting parameter to the piece, as I had enough supporting evidence as to its authenticity.

Same thing for my Rogers letters - they indicate where the pieces came from, but really don't provide any other authentication. If Rogers claimed something was 'Type I' and I needed a letter, I would get someone else to look at it and then toss Rogers' letter.

Rogers is about to spend many years in jail for fraud relating to such photos so I'm pretty certain his LOA's are good solely for toilet paper or fish wrapping.