Old Judge question

[garymc]

I picked up this card about ten years ago and I am now trying to research it. I can't find a photo of my Deacon McGuire ? All the one I found, four so far are different . Can anyone help me ???

[Fred]

There are 4 cataloged poses for McQuire, the picture posted is of pose 312-1.

If I read your post correctly, you indicated you've seen 4 different poses already but not the one you have. That would mean that you've seen an uncataloged pose. I'd get the book called "The Photographic Baseball Cards of Goodwind&Company (1886-1890)" and figure out which pose is not shown in the book. After you get the card you can then sell it to me really cheap.

[garymc]

there is one card that is similar to mine on the PSA site. It has a different old Judge box and the name and team is in script and not a font.

http://www.psacard.com/cardfacts/baseball-cards/1887-old-judge-n172/deacon-mcguire/14519

[garymc]

Another McGuire card fro the collection at the MET.....
http://metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/402632

[z28jd]

There are variations within poses. Team changes will have added value occasionally, but very few people collect variations of the same pose. They either go for one card of a player, or all of the poses for that player.

Here is another example of your particular variation