REA - what'd ya win or lose on?

[T_Hamilton]

First time bidding in this auction and ended up winning lot #705 - 1914 Cracker Jack Honus Wagner SGC 10. First Cracker Jack card ever purchased!

What'd everyone else win or lose on?

[khkco4bls]

I had 60 lots of strictly memorabilia in this auction I'm sure somebody won some of mine

[Billyscards]

was happy about landing the '48 Babe Ruth signed Letter and Book. Missed out on the '24 Game Used WS ball which was pretty neat.

[Bicem]

I had 60 lots of strictly memorabilia in this auction I'm sure somebody won some of mine

How'd you do overall?

[Jersey City Giants]

I won the 10 card lot of Polar Bear T206s 9 PSA 5s and one PSA 6. Not a common back but harder to find in 5 or above.

[shammus]

Very happy with the four lots I won - the e94 with the upside-down back, the tough violet e94 Cobb, the small lot of Obak ghosts (appropriate for Halloween) and my very first postcard, a really nice one of Frank Chance.

I think in this group of four, there were couple I had to pay a little more aggressively for due to competition, but there were also a couple that I won for a really great price so I think it all balances out in my mind.

Regardless of what time it ended, it was a great auction with a wide variety of material. Always happy to take part in an REA auction :)

249849249850249851249852

[Moyni]

I won this and probably overpaid for it but it is my first Wells auto.

I missed out on a Ruth auto and they had a ton of them for sale.

https://sportscardalbum.com/c/5t6b8039x450.jpg (https://sportscardalbum.com/card/5t6b8039)

[Prince Hal]

I won a '33 Goudey Ruth but lost out on the group of D381 Yankees. If anyone bought that lot with the intent of breaking it up I am interested in one of the cards.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Who on earth paid 10K plus for a 56 Mantle in 6.5? :eek::confused:

http://bid.robertedwardauctions.com/bids/bidplace?itemid=41952

[cracker_jack]

Got some upgrades

[Bicem]

Who on earth paid 10K plus for a 56 Mantle in 6.5? :eek::confused:

http://bid.robertedwardauctions.com/bids/bidplace?itemid=41952

Someone confident that he can get it into a 9 holder?

[Stonepony]

Who on earth paid 10K plus for a 56 Mantle in 6.5? :eek::confused:

http://bid.robertedwardauctions.com/bids/bidplace?itemid=41952

That's $7500 more than a PSA 7 Gray back Mantle sold for at Goldin the night prior:eek:

[Peter_Spaeth]

Someone confident that he can get it into a 9 holder?

One would think. Or someone overly influenced by the recent centering mania. :)

[CardMD]

I was the high bidder on the red PSA 5 Cobb forever but got outbid the last day or so and it got out of my price range. Changed my direction and was bidding on the PSA 3 Crackerjack Wagner but that also got above my price range so I 'settled' on picking up two nice Mathewsons (T205 and Brunners). Always wanted a Brunners. I think they are beautiful.

[Snapolit1]

The Brunners are very beautiful. Flirted with the idea of buying one of the larger groupings in RE and taking a run at the set. Didn't pull the trigger.

[khkco4bls]

How'd you do overall?

Overall I did pretty well. some Lots I thought was stolen right out from under me and other ones I did fantastic on like the 38 and 39 Black bats. One thing I learned never group a lot of items together I was not happy about doing that and it didn't work out. The young ladies baseball club broadside also did very well I bought that with eBay years ago for like 400 bucks. The 2 items I was very disappointed on was the Clarkson cigar box and my lemonade set I could not believe that only got 1 bid I thought I would do much better on that item. OH WELL..

[margoaepi]

Picked up the E94 Jennings for what I think was a pretty fair price.

[fduran27]

Picked up the Mars attacks graded set....
:)
I know not baseball, but thought it was a good price.

[Stonepony]

Picked up the Mars attacks graded set....
:)
I know not baseball, but thought it was a good price.

LOVE the set!

[mechanicalman]

I love the Cobb "jumpman" image on the E93s, E94s, and E98s. Also upgraded XX.

[paul]

I was very happy to pick up the E126 Walter Johnson.

[Louieman]

Recently I saw an article, or it may have been a thread on here, of pictures of the Burdick collection at the Met. I loved how he took the 1949 Bowman Paige, Robinson, and Doby cards and displayed them. It's driven me to get strong color /strong registration examples of each. Already have the Paige, and added this one from REA last night!

[pokerplyr80]

Who on earth paid 10K plus for a 56 Mantle in 6.5? :eek::confused:

http://bid.robertedwardauctions.com/bids/bidplace?itemid=41952

Someone started a thread on thag one on the postwar board too. It is puzzling to say the least. A PSA 8 sold in the same auction for less, and the 7.5 much less. And there is a little paper loss in the upper right corner. I'm sure the consignor is pleased.

[itjclarke]

I'd missed one of these on eBay a couple years back and regretted it. Ended up going a little higher than I wanted, but snagged this one last night.

Couldn't be happier with REA service overall. I called with an issue (that's since resolved itself) and they picked up, were very polite and responsive, and I knew they'd take care of it if needed. I was surprised by the earlier bid deadline, but as it played out, it seemed really smooth. May have been more difficult had I been out and about yesterday, but there's really no perfect "catch all" solution for everyone in every locale.

[MR RAREBACK]

I was the under bidder on the Mathewson epdg nice card

[darwinbulldog]

One win: http://bid.robertedwardauctions.com/bids/bidplace?itemid=41588

[edjs]

One win: http://bid.robertedwardauctions.com/bids/bidplace?itemid=41588

Nice, Glenn. Same graded card sold on e-bay recently for a bunch more moola. I was on the fence on that one, but I committed my money a few days before and was out on everything from REA. The Clements are really nice. I didn't win anything at REA, but I don't feel I lost either, since I got something I really have wanted for a long time now instead.

[Snapolit1]

Shut out. Liked a few of the old photos but didn't go high enough.

Glad to see the Jackie 48 Leaf PSA 7 went for something like $24,000. Equally glad no one bought my SGC 80 last month on B/S/T for $6,500, which looks at least as nice as that 7.

[bwbc917]

Congrats to the winners, I bailed on the Uzit Berger and D381 Speaker at 1200.

[kdixon]

Picked up this Wheat. I had one and sold it several years ago. Had always regretted it.

[Scott L.]

Always wanted this card. Happy to finally own one. I think it presents pretty nicely for the grade and I was happy with the price. Really excited to have it.

http://i299.photobucket.com/albums/mm301/slatsko/IMG_0248_zpst2fgyqgb.jpg

[btcarfagno]

I got skunked. Even went balls to the wall on one lot and doubled what I had budgeted and still was underbidder.

Gah!!

Tom C

[Snapolit1]

Feel your pain, but so many good auctions coming. Upcoming Heritage Auction is great. Also Love of the Game. And of course another PWCC raring up. More fish in the sea as they say.

[Mighty Casey]

Under bidder on a '29 Kashin Ruth. Dang!

[brian29575]

Always wanted this card and finally won one last night!

http://i746.photobucket.com/albums/xx108/brian29575/Mobile%20Uploads/image_zpsgat5j4et.jpg

[clydepepper]

Recently I saw an article, or it may have been a thread on here, of pictures of the Burdick collection at the Met. I loved how he took the 1949 Bowman Paige, Robinson, and Doby cards and displayed them. It's driven me to get strong color /strong registration examples of each. Already have the Paige, and added this one from REA last night!

Great Doby, Louie! That's been one of my favorite cards for years.

[brian29575]

Always wanted this card. Happy to finally own one. I think it presents pretty nicely for the grade and I was happy with the price. Really excited to have it.

http://i299.photobucket.com/albums/mm301/slatsko/IMG_0248_zpst2fgyqgb.jpg

Awesome looking PSA 1

[Bosox Blair]

Congrats to everyone who landed something - nice stuff shown here!

I was bidding on about 30 pre-war lots - most went for what I considered fair market value, a couple went way higher, and a couple were good bargains. This is my 10th year of bidding with REA and I feel like I could have said the same about most of the REA auctions over that timeframe.

(Cannot comment on post-war as I don't care about that at all, and I am frankly baffled and a bit bemused by what has happened recently with these very common, mass-produced cards.)

In terms of the new closing format, I found it to be fine. I am a West Coaster, so usually was told by East Coast friends that I had a big advantage. This one came out no better or worse for me...about the same I'd say! (Even though I was out for dinner when it closed, and I used my phone to monitor the auction for the very first time. Worked well...even if I felt a bit rude at dinner...lol.)

Cheers,
Blair

[kailes2872]

I had early bids in on about 15 lots. I ended up getting shut out. The bummer was that the next bet with BP put it out of my range. I was really interested in the DeLong set, the Tattoo Orbit set and the Diamond Stars set. While the prices were VERY reasonable - I decided to wait until the spring when I am flush with more cash. The 54 Bowman set went for $1000. The Ted Williams Fleer went for $800 and had a PSA 7 Teds signed. There was a lot of value out there.

Hopefully, the prices stay reasonable for the spring auction and I can get some pre-war complete sets.

[btcarfagno]

Always wanted this card and finally won one last night!

http://i746.photobucket.com/albums/xx108/brian29575/Mobile%20Uploads/image_zpsgat5j4et.jpg

I assume that has to have some back damage...because from the front that sure ain't no SGC 10.

Beauty!

Tom C

[1952boyntoncollector]

Shut out. Liked a few of the old photos but didn't go high enough.

Glad to see the Jackie 48 Leaf PSA 7 went for something like $24,000. Equally glad no one bought my SGC 80 last month on B/S/T for $6,500, which looks at least as nice as that 7.

the guy that paid all that cash for the 1956 psa 6.5 mantle will give you 50k for your leaf jackie

[Scott L.]

I assume that has to have some back damage...because from the front that sure ain't no SGC 10.

Beauty!

Tom C

Agreed. Looks tremendous!

[jp1216]

'52 Mantle - yep, paper loss but WOW that's a nice one to look at. Congrats!

http://bid.robertedwardauctions.com/bids/bidplace?itemid=41862

[Thromdog]

I ended up getting the EPDG lot. I think 7 of the 10 could be the highest graded.....should I send them back to PSA for new holders? Not sure how that works.

The Smith card is my white whale. I've never seen one for sale and cannot find any record of one being sold. Absolutely thrilled to have him.

211 uniques!

http://i856.photobucket.com/albums/ab121/thromdog/t206/D738DC17-E2ED-4727-9CF6-6270939AD79F.jpeg

http://i856.photobucket.com/albums/ab121/thromdog/t206/BEA93951-61D1-432C-8047-85CD4E5BD045.jpeg

[Bosox Blair]

I ended up getting the EPDG lot. I think 7 of the 10 could be the highest graded.....should I send them back to PSA for new holders? Not sure how that works.



Congrats on the beautiful cards!

As you probably know, all of these EPDGs in your lot were graded before PSA had half-points. So, if you feel these are real strong 6s, you could pay to have them re-graded - seeking the half-point bump - and re-holdered in the new and improved holders that are meant to be more secure.

Cheers,
Blair

[Louieman]

Great Doby, Louie! That's been one of my favorite cards for years.

Thank you sir!

[ValKehl]

I was hoping the SGC "A" grade would enable me to win this N370 Lone Jack for my limit of not more than $3,000. :(
http://bid.robertedwardauctions.com/bids/bidplace?itemid=40978

If anyone here won the lot of nine T222s and is looking to flip the Nemo Leibold card, I'd be most interested.
Val

[jefferyepayne]

If anyone won the Kellogg's Pep Sports Stamps near set and plans to break it up and sell it, I'm looking for #1, #3, and #5 from that set and would be interested in buying them from you.

http://bid.robertedwardauctions.com/bids/bidplace?itemid=43033

jeff

[Snapolit1]

the guy that paid all that cash for the 1956 psa 6.5 mantle will give you 50k for your leaf jackie

Excellent! Do you have his contact info. Hopefully not a mental institution somewhere.

[brob28]

Always wanted this card. Happy to finally own one. I think it presents pretty nicely for the grade and I was happy with the price. Really excited to have it.

http://i299.photobucket.com/albums/mm301/slatsko/IMG_0248_zpst2fgyqgb.jpg

I gave some serious consideration to that one, glad a Net54 member got it. Congrats.

[Snapolit1]

Love that Ruth. That card always seems to capture the essence of Ruth to me. The other end of the spectrum is that dopey CJ where he looks like a drunk with his hat falling off.

[aad0906]

I won the E95 set as well as the T206 Demmitt St Louis and various scarce back T206's

[mechanicalman]

Love that Ruth. That card always seems to capture the essence of Ruth to me. The other end of the spectrum is that dopey CJ where he looks like a drunk with his hat falling off.

Ruth CJ? Do you mean the PSA National give-away?

[Gobucsmagic74]

Ruth CJ? Do you mean the PSA National give-away?

I think he's referring to the 1932 US Caramel

[Snapolit1]

I think he's referring to the 1932 US Caramel

Yep, the Caramel. My error.

[Bobsbats]

Who on earth paid 10K plus for a 56 Mantle in 6.5? :eek::confused:

http://bid.robertedwardauctions.com/bids/bidplace?itemid=41952

Someone must have been bidding them up on the price too !! Two people that want that card for close to 10K....SMH

[CMIZ5290]

T206 SGC 84 Tinker Uzit, someone got a good buy....

[CMIZ5290]

Someone must have been bidding them up on the price too !! Two people that want that card for close to 10K....SMH

56 Mantle PSA 6.5? This is the card that makes absolutely no sense to me, absolutely none....There also looks like some weird stuff going on with the reverse.... People looking for a higher graded 56 Mantle would know that there are plenty for the taking based upon the numbers....

[Scott L.]

I gave some serious consideration to that one, glad a Net54 member got it. Congrats.

Thanks Bill. I appreciate it!

[Blunder19]

one of my wins...love the no name....


http://i251.photobucket.com/albums/gg309/blunder19/T206%20Burch%20Proof_zps9w68p5hl.jpg (http://s251.photobucket.com/user/blunder19/media/T206%20Burch%20Proof_zps9w68p5hl.jpg.html)
http://i251.photobucket.com/albums/gg309/blunder19/T206%20Burch%20Proof%20back_zpsnbsscdv6.jpg (http://s251.photobucket.com/user/blunder19/media/T206%20Burch%20Proof%20back_zpsnbsscdv6.jpg.html)

[tbob]

Finally got the extremely tough violet E94 Cy Young to complete the 6 different colored E94 Young fronts.
I thought the E,94s, both regular and overprinted backs and E98s, both regular and Old Put backs, went for really reasonable prices. I wanted to jump on some as duplicates because of the good prices but stayed focused on the prize :-)

[Sean]

one of my wins...love the no name....


http://i251.photobucket.com/albums/gg309/blunder19/T206%20Burch%20Proof_zps9w68p5hl.jpg (http://s251.photobucket.com/user/blunder19/media/T206%20Burch%20Proof_zps9w68p5hl.jpg.html)
http://i251.photobucket.com/albums/gg309/blunder19/T206%20Burch%20Proof%20back_zpsnbsscdv6.jpg (http://s251.photobucket.com/user/blunder19/media/T206%20Burch%20Proof%20back_zpsnbsscdv6.jpg.html)

Great proof card. I really would like to get one someday, but at that price it isn't likely. :)

[OriolesHOF]

Adding to my Jack Dunn back run, I won the T206 of Babe's legal guardian with a Cycle 350 reverse.

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

some of the t205 bulk lots were still reasonable last I looked, just didn't have the money to pull the trigger.

[Jason]

I was the underbidder on the Old Mill Cabinet Dutch Revelle entering extended bidding. I wouldnt exactly say I lost it though as I never was really in the running obviously with the 7k+ closing price!

It wasnt a total loss though quite the opposite. Of the 7 lots I had bids on I was able to pick up the Series 4 Benny card which has eluded me for a few years partially from my own mistakes. The addition brings me to needing just Dougherty for completion of Series 4.

[Leon]

Finally got the extremely tough violet E94 Cy Young to complete the 6 different colored E94 Young fronts.
I thought the E,94s, both regular and overprinted backs and E98s, both regular and Old Put backs, went for really reasonable prices. I wanted to jump on some as duplicates because of the good prices but stayed focused on the prize :-)

Congrats Bob....a few years ago that would have cost 2x as much...

[mechanicalman]

Congrats Bob....a few years ago that would have cost 2x as much...

I love that e94 Cy. Leon, I'm curious about your comment as I'm relatively new to the hobby. Is there any reason the prices on those have fallen as much as they have? Was it symptomatic of all e-cards? Just less demand, or was there a population change? I'm starting to get into these cards and am trying to learn as much as I can. Appreciate anyone's thoughts.

[aconte]

Was happy to win this item!

[Yoda]

I was very pleased with what I picked up, given the quality of items on offer and what I assumed to be record setting prices soon to be achieved. The best value from a dealer standpoint was the lot won of 7 T202's, which included nice specimens of Matty, WoJo, Cy and Tinker/Evers/Chance. Also won was:-
N172 McClellan, Denver Outdoor Pose
Display Piece of Horner Photo/M116 card of Harry Smith, which will look great in my office.

[baztacula]

Well this went for about $1000 more than I thought it would. I exited the site after $500 was surpassed...

http://bid.robertedwardauctions.com/bids/bidplace?itemid=41454

[Edwolf1963]

Finally got the extremely tough violet E94 Cy Young to complete the 6 different colored E94 Young fronts.
I thought the E,94s, both regular and overprinted backs and E98s, both regular and Old Put backs, went for really reasonable prices. I wanted to jump on some as duplicates because of the good prices but stayed focused on the prize :-)

Nice pick-up! I had an initial bid on that one, then stayed off and focused on others. I have it in red, more focused on completing a set rather than a color string .. though an amazing thing (IMO) to be be able to stay focused and do that!

I won some of the other E94's, most were dupes/upgrades though. I agree that the prices were pretty reasonable compared to what I thought they might go for.

The E98's .. in some respects I thought along the lines of what you may expect, but that E98 Chance PSA8 went a lot higher (w/juice) than I thought it would have or recent sales may have suggested. That's a hard group to judge with shifts in demand, HOF vs. no, high/low end, Black Swamp, etc. Congrats again on that purple Young!

[Bosox Blair]

Patience pays off again...3.5 year wait saved me over $8,200 on this gem. I bid back in 2013, but bailed out long before this went over $14,000 then...much happier with the 2016 price, needless to say:

[Leon]

Patience pays off again...3.5 year wait saved me over $8,200 on this gem. I bid back in 2013, but bailed out long before this went over $14,000 then...much happier with the 2016 price, needless to say:

I was the under bidder the first time it sold and couldn't be happier for the winner the first time. :) Congrats on a great card!!

[t213]

I won the Virginia Extra, my first one with that back.
Andy

[sox1903wschamp]

Patience pays off again...3.5 year wait saved me over $8,200 on this gem. I bid back in 2013, but bailed out long before this went over $14,000 then...much happier with the 2016 price, needless to say:

Nice, congrats.