Ruth Gehrig cut opinions

[w7imel]

Saw this Ruth and Gehrig cut that has been authenticated by both PSA and JSA. Does this piece look ok to you guys? What are the chances of these two signatures on a cut both mint? They may both be fine but it just seemed odd to me. Any one else not combfortable with this one or am i the crazy one?:D The seller does go to great detail about the item this always reassures me as well.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/PSA-DNA-JSA-Mint-9-Babe-Ruth-Lou-Gehrig-signed-auto-cut-Finest-example-Yankees-/291616046441?hash=item43e5abbd69:g:Jz8AAOSwEgVWRna z

[theshleps]

ugh

[w7imel]

Kind of what I thought...the Ruth looks like it was drawn, I mean signed yesterday IMO. It would make me real jittery to spend 15K on this cut.

[RichardSimon]

I always love it when sellers think they have to include mini-biographies about Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig.

[w7imel]

Those were almost full life stories:):)

[Augy44]

I can't speak on authenticity, but here's where the cut originated. Sold for $4,400 back in 2009.

http://robertedwardauctions.com/auction/2009/935.html

[khkco4bls]

Who's Lau gehrig

[MooseDog]

What are the odds that whoever "may" have cut the autographs out of the book would match exactly to the closeup provided in the REA auction?? I'd be inclined to believe the eBay auction item is a color copy of the small REA picture.

[RichardSimon]

What are the odds that whoever "may" have cut the autographs out of the book would match exactly to the closeup provided in the REA auction?? I'd be inclined to believe the eBay auction item is a color copy of the small REA picture.

That would not surprise me.
That is what frames are for ;).