Question on 1970 Action Cartridges

[RobertC]

What would sell better - a complete 1970 Action Cartridge, a graded Action Cartridge box, or cutting out the "card" and having it graded? I bought a small lot of these to get a Hank Aaron one, and I am left with four others that I don't want. The boxes are definitely not perfect, but I think I might be able to get four nice looking cards off them. BTW, I have Tom Seaver, Willie Davis, Brooks Robinson, and Lou Brock - pm me if anyone is interested in one. Thanks.

[quitcrab]

I don't recall a "card" to be cut off an action cartridge box
I would be interested in the Brooks item
I always wanted to watch the Brooks cartridge. Do you have the camera for viewing a cartridge ? Thanks. Scott

[RobertC]

I have seen PSA graded examples of the picture on the front of the box cut out - it is nearly the same size as a regular card. I have also seen the front of the box cut out and graded, as well as the entire box graded.

[David W]

I mostly see the intact box with cartridge on eBay. I have Lou Brock all 3 ways. I doubt I paid more than $10 dollars for any of them. There are quite a few on eBay right now

[Exhibitman]

Good question. I picked up a complete box with cartridge and instruction sheet for my Aaron collection and have wondered how to deal with it ever since. And where do you have to cut it?

http://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/VpYAAOSw5VFWNUgG/s-l1600.jpg

http://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/~KsAAOSw7hRWOi~E/s-l1600.jpg

Or do you just get the whole box slabbed?

http://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/jyoAAOSwT5tWOadA/s-l1600.jpg

[RobertC]

Check the PSA Baseball Player Registry, Hank Aaron master set owned by mas715 to see a graded one. The "card" looks like this:

[Mark70Z]

I don't think any of the cartridges were ever designed to be cards, but as stated there are all states of the box/s being graded. I personally like the whole box graded if anything.

[RobertC]

I like the whole box graded, too, but I can also see taking a damaged low grade box and cutting a high grade "card" out of it.

[mrmopar]

What are you asking for the Davis? I think I have one, but can't remember now. I'll have to check the Dodger oddball boxes if I can dig them out.