Roberto Clemente-Phil Dorsey Signed

[thetruthisoutthere]

Sometime ago a few of the members here asked for examples of a Phil Dorsey signed Roberto Clemente.

I keep my exemplars to myself, but the one below I can show.

It is presently on the Mears Auction site and it is a Phil Dorsey signed Roberto Clemente.



http://sports.mearsonlineauctions.com/1960_s_Roberto_Clemente_Pittsburgh_Pirates_Signed_-LOT91592.aspx




206199

[GrayGhost]

dumb question Chris, but does JSA know bout this guy and are just not too bright? or they don't care or both?

[thetruthisoutthere]

Not a dumb question, Scott.

I don't think JSA examined that "Clemente."

It doesn't come with a full JSA COA; just an "auction letter."

[GrayGhost]

Not a dumb question, Scott.

I don't think JSA examined that "Clemente."

It doesn't come with a full JSA COA; just an "auction letter."

that would make sense. Ive seen a ton of that photo "signed" . they r all done by this guy?

[RichardSimon]

How do they issue an auction letter on a Clemente autograph?
Doesn't a Clemente autograph deserve a full examination?

[thetruthisoutthere]

How do they issue an auction letter on a Clemente autograph?
Doesn't a Clemente autograph deserve a full examination?

+1

Absolutely.

[HRBAKER]

Has anyone shared with MEARS that they are auctioning a Phil Dorsey autograph?

[Duluth Eskimo]

I am not good with Clemente and generally rely on a few friends who are heavy Clemente collectors, but weren't many of these Dorsey's fully authenticated by the big two before it was discovered these were done by Dorsey? I do not know when this info became largely known, but maybe someone else could expand on this. Jason

[thetruthisoutthere]

I went back to the auction and the description now reads "Secretarial signature."


http://sports.mearsonlineauctions.com/1960_s_Roberto_Clemente_Pittsburgh_Pirates_Signed_-LOT91592.aspx

[nickth]

https://image.prntscr.com/image/m5XwoCunTTS8PrVJt1nEpA.png

Is it an authentic Roberto Clemente or a Phil Dorsey?

Would you please post a Phil Dorsey Roberto Clemente signature image for comparison?