If You Could Take One Card From Someone Here...

[MetsBaseball1973]

Let's all face it: healthy envy is part of collecting. It's a nice compliment to pay another collector. As I see the great cards posted here on a regular basis, it made me think of a fun what if...

Assume you could take any ONE card from any one collector here. Which would it be and why? I'm going to do some super fun virtual shopping here for the next few hours and really think this through before making my pick...

[pawpawdiv9]

At first, I'd say one of MattyC's cards, either the Mick52 or his Ruth RC.
but i know theres guys on here with very rare cards that people would love and never get a hand on, unless adopted.
I know of a post war guy with a Mick dice game card thats rare for post-war
As for pre-war. Almost anything RC wise of any HoF'er.

[Enfuego]

At first, I'd say one of MattyC's cards, either the Mick52 or his Ruth RC.
but i know theres guys on here with very rare cards that people would love and never get a hand on, unless adopted.
I know of a post war guy with a Mick dice game card thats rare for post-war
As for pre-war. Almost anything RC wise of any HoF'er.

I too would grab the Bambino RC as well!

[ErikV]

Hands down, the one card I wish I owned...

[kkkkandp]

This is a sort of easy one - as Jay Miller is Mr. OJ and my collection pales in comparison to his I would love to grab one of the toughies he has to fill a hole in my collection. The hard part is picking just one.

I wouldn't be overly greedy by trying to glom a California League card, for instance, but a Jake Wells or a Peek-A-Boo Veach would do nicely. Alternatively, I would take a Tug Wilson to replace the one I had to sell to fund some of the repairs to my house.

[darwinbulldog]

I think I have to go with this Wagner from Leon's collection. I don't mind mentioning it now since I have no chance of affording it when it hits the auction block in July. It would be a decent candidate even without the tab.

http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=190332

[MetsBaseball1973]

At first, I'd say one of MattyC's cards, either the Mick52 or his Ruth RC.
but i know theres guys on here with very rare cards that people would love and never get a hand on, unless adopted.
I know of a post war guy with a Mick dice game card thats rare for post-war
As for pre-war. Almost anything RC wise of any HoF'er.

Hysterical-- after spending all this time browsing as many pics as I can, I have also decided on MattyC's Ruth Rookie, followed closely by his Mantle, as I am a centering guy.

To me, his "1.5" Ruth is the prime hobby example of how the grade is so far from the whole story. I mean 5's that don't look nearly as good as his Ruth cost 90k and I think he paid in the 50's for it. Plus I have never seen one centered better in any grade.

[slipk1068]

Leon's Matty proof is probably my favorite.

[Bicem]

Lichtman's American League Publishing Cobb.

[4815162342]

I think I have to go with this Wagner from Leon's collection. I don't mind mentioning it now since I have no chance of affording it when it hits the auction block in July. It would be a decent candidate even without the tab.

http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=190332

Leon's Matty proof is probably my favorite.

I have a feeling that a lot of cards from the LLCF* are going to be posted in this thread. :D

*LLCF = Leon Luckey College Fund

[MattyC]

I would take PCoz's Frederick Foto Ruth followed by Joe T's 1914 Mathewson CJ!

Paw and Mets, thank you both very much for the kind words on these two:

http://www.collectorfocus.com/images/show/MattyC/-the-core-four-/23610/1916-m101-babe-ruth

http://www.collectorfocus.com/images/show/MattyC/the-museum-mantle/26308/museum-mick

[Howe’s Hunter]

Between Josh Jones' Cy Young side view, Jeremy J's Hindu-backed Bernhard (what is with all the J initials?) and another member's Hindu-back Killian, I'd probably take Josh's Cy Young. Not the rare back, but with it, I would have all three poses of Cy Young with Howe's stamp on the back.

[Bpm0014]

T206Collector's T206 signed Cy Young or Walter Johnson...

[GregMitch34]

I am open (this week) to any offer of a PSA 5 or better CJ 14! Though this will pass!

[Kawika]

Would love any of the Thad Wilkerson NY ballpark postcards. Not sure whose they are.

[edjs]

Do I have to know who owns it? If not, I would want this one:

[sycks22]

Would love to have the N172 Cap Anson Uniform or Maple Crispette Stengel.

[chipperhank44]

Without a doubt it would be Jeff's Detroit Free Press Cobb PC

[x2drich2000]

I'm a bit surprised no one has mentioned one of the t206 Wagners or Planks owned by board members. Personally, even though I don't know the particular member who owns it, I would go for the Just So Cy Young. Coming back into the realm of semi-reality, I would go with Leon's Pinkerton Cobb.

DJ

[buymycards]

Leon's Cafe du Monde card. Real scarce, cool card, and from my favorite place.

[edjs]

I'm a bit surprised no one has mentioned one of the t206 Wagners or Planks owned by board members. Personally, even though I don't know the particular member who owns it, I would go for the Just So Cy Young. Coming back into the realm of semi-reality, I would go with Leon's Pinkerton Cobb.

DJ

Of course I thought about those, but they are the obvious choices. I wanted to go more obscure. However, I had forgot about the Just So, which is truly a remarkable card. I would still have a hard time not choosing an E224 Joe Jackson.

[DeanH3]

So many that it's hard to choose. But two that come to mind are Leon's Kotton Cobb and CW's CJ Cobb.

Edited to add Chuck's E102 Cobb as well. ;)

[peterose4hof]

I'd like to have Leon's Peck & Snyder Reds card.

Please .... Pretty Please! :D

[Econteachert205]

I'd take Leon's t205 McGraw scrap.

[CW]

Ha! cool thread...

Thanks, Dean!

I'd grab either David M's 1914 CJ Mathewson or Jeff L's H.C. Hubel Cobb PC, both posted here vicariously...

(honorable mention to Matt's '52 Mantle)

http://photos.imageevent.com/kawika_o_ka_pakipika/sportscardsetc/baseball/holygrailcards/large/qu14%20CJ%20Matty.jpg

https://c1.staticflickr.com/5/4080/5413072853_96a1428015_b.jpg

[insccollectibles]

This is a tough one but I would say Chris's T206 Gibson Blank Back Ghost is probable the card I would want most.

[z28jd]

I would take Kevin Cummings Larry Corcoran OJ because I don't like him having one. When can we actually do this? I want my card!

[William Todd]

I would love to own this card

[atx840]

Has to be Leon's proof. Top HOF, Type-1 no name design change, fat handcut borders, blank backed proof. Doesn't get any better than that for me.

http://i.imgur.com/G5BMCht.jpg

[Kawika]

Chuck: Only card I've ever submitted for a re-grade. I've seen 2's that were roadkill and thought this beauty deserved better. SGC gave it a wee bump.
http://photos.imageevent.com/kawika_o_ka_pakipika/sportscardsetc/baseball/bbhofthefirstclass/huge/14CJ%20Matty1.jpg

[Wite3]

I would love Dan's Felin's Frank card...

Joshua

[calvindog]

Chuck: Only card I've ever submitted for a re-grade. I've seen 2's that were roadkill and thought this beauty deserved better. SGC gave it a wee bump.
http://photos.imageevent.com/kawika_o_ka_pakipika/sportscardsetc/baseball/bbhofthefirstclass/huge/14CJ%20Matty1.jpg

My favorite card of anyone's on this board -- and I agree, very undergraded.

Here's my other two mentioned above:

https://c2.staticflickr.com/4/3195/3019102393_a3ff2c0f8e_o.jpg (https://flic.kr/p/5AMFXx)

https://c2.staticflickr.com/4/3015/3084954078_9c63d1ab56_o.jpg (https://flic.kr/p/5GBcnq)

[kmac32]

I would appropriate Kevin Andrew's 1921 E121 O'Leary card for my collection

[ejharrington]

Not a card but RobSteinmetz has Dave Kingman's "Babe Ruth Crown", given to him in 1980 in honor of his amazing offensive season in 1979 with the Cubs. Absolutely awesome!

[Joshwesley]

Hold up.... Someone on here has a t206 Wagner and an eddie plank?

Someone have pics of that?

Wow.

[CW]

Chuck: Only card I've ever submitted for a re-grade. I've seen 2's that were roadkill and thought this beauty deserved better. SGC gave it a wee bump.


SO nice, David! I'll shoot you a PM for directions so I can come over and pick it up. Thanks!

:cool:

[oldjudge]

Since Kevin is taking one of mine, it is only fair that I take Corey's Creighton Peck and Snyder.

[Jobu]

Short of cards worth as much as a house, I would take one of Leon's cards that i will share after I don't win it. In second place would be the T213-1 Matty dark cap - I would happily take either Ted Z's or Dean H.'s (hi fellas, still love your cards).

[SMPEP]

EASY call for me - a 1952 Topps Reiser grey back. Assuming that whoever owns one of the three known ones is a member of this board that is!

Cheers,
Patrick

[kmac32]

EASY call for me - a 1952 Topps Reiser grey back. Assuming that whoever owns one of the three known ones is a member of this board that is!

Cheers,
Patrick

I thought in might be a 1923 W572 Cadore. LOL

[Bliggity]

Dan's H's uncut W551 panel. So cool. All day long.

http://i1383.photobucket.com/albums/ah316/dmblau/Mobile%20Uploads/W551RuthCobbpanel_zpsk7wgrcie.jpg

[kmac32]

actually I would also gladly take any E121 Ruth except for Ruth with bird for my E121 Yankees/ Giants WS collection.

[Joshchisox08]

I don't even own a Cobb. He's my favorite player of all time and although I like the Green portrait better the Red is my second fav. Throw in the rare back and It would be the second to none for me unless it was a Green the only way it could be better.

I'm now accepting donations Rob Blake :D

[kkkkandp]

I would take Kevin Cummings Larry Corcoran OJ because I don't like him having one. When can we actually do this? I want my card!

My initial thought was to take one of your Corcorans because you have just too damned many! :D

[kkkkandp]

Since Kevin is taking one of mine, it is only fair that I take Corey's Creighton Peck and Snyder.

I'll take someone else's if you just find a willing donor! :D

[Rich Klein]

Leon's Fan card of Home Run Baker (I know he is giving it up soon but for now.,..)

[pbspelly]

Someone on the board has these. Can't recall who. But I want them both.

[Joshchisox08]

Someone on the board has these. Can't recall who. But I want them both.


Billy Sullivan fan or a Sox fan ?

[triwak]

The 1909 Cabanas Pete Hill card (can't recall the board member's name right now)? Yep. Would be that one.

[Sean]

I don't even own a Cobb. He's my favorite player of all time and although I like the Green portrait better the Red is my second fav. Throw in the rare back and It would be the second to none for me unless it was a Green the only way it could be better.

I'm now accepting donations Rob Blake :D

Hey Josh, good news: it's for sale! :rolleyes: :D

[Bigb13]

Always a smart ass in the crowd.

[Joshchisox08]

Hey Josh, good news: it's for sale! :rolleyes: :D

It's been for sale. But this is if we could have a card off the board what would you pick. I'd chose that Cobb.

[SMPEP]

Ken - I considered a 1923 W572 Rapp or Barbare - but the Reiser is higher on the priority list!

Cheers,
Patrick

[vintagehofrookies]

I want these and that 1905 Tigers team Sporting Life(I think that's it) for a member who I can't recall


My favorite card of anyone's on this board -- and I agree, very undergraded.

Here's my other two mentioned above:

https://c2.staticflickr.com/4/3195/3019102393_a3ff2c0f8e_o.jpg (https://flic.kr/p/5AMFXx)

https://c2.staticflickr.com/4/3015/3084954078_9c63d1ab56_o.jpg (https://flic.kr/p/5GBcnq)

[calvindog]

https://c2.staticflickr.com/6/5047/5342975261_104f0371b5_b.jpg (https://flic.kr/p/9999p8)

[Sean]

Always a smart ass in the crowd.

Yeah, I'll plead guilty on this one.

But look on the bright side: Josh picked your card as the one card he most wanted. No one has mentioned any of my cards.

[bwbc917]

There was a lovely Lajoie Novelty Cutlery for sale in B/S/T. Would love to have been able to afford it.

[edjs]

Yeah, I'll plead guilty on this one.

But look on the bright side: Josh picked your card as the one card he most wanted. No one has mentioned any of my cards.

Or mine....I can't figure out why? :confused::confused:

[vintagehofrookies]

https://c2.staticflickr.com/6/5047/5342975261_104f0371b5_b.jpg (https://flic.kr/p/9999p8)
Jeff,
that's the PC but the one from 1905 is the one I fancy,

Dan

[atx840]

Yeah, I'll plead guilty on this one.

But look on the bright side: Josh picked your card as the one card he most wanted. No one has mentioned any of my cards.

Sean, your plank is #3 on my list. :cool:

[glenv]

As a type collector, I'd have to go with Leon's or John's T231

191068 191069

[Baseball Rarities]

Jeff,
that's the PC but the one from 1905 is the one I fancy,

Dan

Dan - that is the only year that The Sporting Life made a team postcard set. That postcard is generally considered Cobb's earliest appearance on a "card."

Maybe you were thinking of a 1905 The Sporting Life premium?

[4815162342]

https://c2.staticflickr.com/6/5047/5342975261_104f0371b5_b.jpg (https://flic.kr/p/9999p8)

Ty looks like a little baby in that composite.

http://ebid.s3.amazonaws.com/upload_big/6/7/5/1266679759-24630-0.jpg

[Pat R]

To many great cards to choose from so maybe the best option would be one
of these.

[4815162342]

To many great cards to choose from so maybe the best option would be one
of these.

Patrick, you're on the right track.

http://static0.bornrichimages.com/wp-content/uploads/s3/images/2007/10/05/amex-black-1_48.jpg

[calvindog]

Dan - that is the only year that The Sporting Life made a team postcard set. That postcard is generally considered Cobb's earliest appearance on a "card."

Maybe you were thinking of a 1905 The Sporting Life premium?

Kevin took the words out of my mouth.

[bnorth]

I have no idea who owns this card but it is #1 for me.

[MartyFromCANADA]

EASY for me;

I want Richard's 1910 Orange Border George Gibson

[pawpawdiv9]

Ty looks like a little baby in that composite.

http://ebid.s3.amazonaws.com/upload_big/6/7/5/1266679759-24630-0.jpg


Funny how you bring that up about Ty Cobb. There was a special insert in my Atlanta Newspaper on Ty Cobb. Back in his early days playing for Royston Reds. It had a nice pic of him with 4 kids showing he was born in Northeast Georgia where he got his start. Then there was another team photo in the 1890's where he looked very young, much like that one posted here.
** I will see to scan those photos and the reading material for ya guys. Or maybe you can see it in the Atlanta Journal-Constitution dated Sunday May 17th. It was in the E-section called Living & Arts.

UPDATE with some PICS from newspaper:
http://i1240.photobucket.com/albums/gg481/kylerowdybusch/Scan_Pic0048_zpspdtw7n3m.jpg (http://s1240.photobucket.com/user/kylerowdybusch/media/Scan_Pic0048_zpspdtw7n3m.jpg.html)

http://s1240.photobucket.com/user/kylerowdybusch/media/Scan_Pic0048_zpspdtw7n3m.jpg.html

http://i1240.photobucket.com/albums/gg481/kylerowdybusch/Scan_Pic0047_zpsujd58qjj.jpg (http://s1240.photobucket.com/user/kylerowdybusch/media/Scan_Pic0047_zpsujd58qjj.jpg.html)

[vintagehofrookies]

Dan - that is the only year that The Sporting Life made a team postcard set. That postcard is generally considered Cobb's earliest appearance on a "card."

Maybe you were thinking of a 1905 The Sporting Life premium?

Yes Kevin! thats it!

[frohme]

I think I have to go with this Wagner from Leon's collection. I don't mind mentioning it now since I have no chance of affording it when it hits the auction block in July. It would be a decent candidate even without the tab.

http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=190332

When I saw the original post, my answer came to mind instantly ... and while I have the same sentiment as Glenn on Leon's upcoming divestiture - so to speak - its for a different reason, namely:

http://net54baseball.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=19774&stc=1&d=1275158159

--
Mike

[Jobu]

Hey now, let's try to keep this thread clean - there might be minors reading this.

:D

Sean, your plank is #3 on my list. :cool:

[pbspelly]

Billy Sullivan fan or a Sox fan ?

Sullivan relative