Need help on NY GIants postcards

[RichardSimon]

I am trying to find value and any info about these three postcards.
Thanks in advance for any help.

[bcbgcbrcb]

Richard:

I would guess somewhere around $200 - $300 each on the last two, maybe around $100 on the top one.

[RichardSimon]

Phil,
Thanks very much.
Any ID on those cards?

[bcbgcbrcb]

Richard:

I think the Marquard is American Publishing or something like that, not sure of the source for the other two.

[bgar3]

I believe the bottom one is the 1912 Giants, despite earlier photos at the top.

[RichardSimon]

I believe the bottom one is the 1912 Giants, despite earlier photos at the top.

I found one, in fair condition,that sold on ebay recently.
The seller called the postcard circa 1910.

[bgar3]

I guess technically it is "circa 1910", but more specifically, the team shot is the 1912 World Series team. The photos above are from different years, I think earlier than 1912. It would make sense to issue this for the World Series, so circa 1912 not only would be more accurate, but should be be a little more valuable. I am fairly positive I once had a large mounted cabinet photo of that team shot, and that one very clearly was the 1912 team.

[RichardSimon]

Thanks bgar.

[VintageBall]

That bottom card is extremely rare. I've seen it only once before and that card was owned by Ron Menchine who gave it to the grandson of a friend of his.

The grandson later sold it privately at a NY postcard show for $450 around three years ago.

The one in the middle is from Max Stein's U.S. Publishing house. Here is a link to a bunch of Max Stein cards, including 2 U.S. Publishing House ones: http://www.vintageball.com/MaxStein.html.

Best,

Robert S