Thurman Munson Auto.. Good or Clubhouse?

[yanks12025]

Is this a real Munson or a clubhouse? I believe the ball is a 1979 team signed. The munson looks like a older style auto. Comparing it to most autos on 1977-79 balls his normal auto is smaller.

[UnVme7]

This is the one from EBay right? Someone emailed me asking about it.

[joed25]

Fake

[yanks12025]

This is the one from EBay right? Someone emailed me asking about it.

Yes

[daves_resale_shop]

No good imo...

Doesn't look like Thurman's hand to me...

[Duluth Eskimo]

I would agree no good IMO. Looks too slowly written and too neat.

[yanks12025]

Thanks guys. What do you think of these other autos on the ball. Like I said its a 1979 yankee ball.

[yanks12025]

One more panel. Sorry posting from iPad so can only do 1 per post

[yanks12025]

Last one... Do any look good or all clubhouse.http://img.tapatalk.com/d/14/02/18/esa8edan.jpg

[joed25]

The Yogi looks real

[Lordstan]

I think most of the signatures look real. The only one, beside Munson, that concerns me, is the Nettles as the ink is much darker and the sig is in a form I am not familiar with. I would say the Munson is a clubhouse version.

[RichardSimon]

Munson definitely clubhouse.

[MooseDog]

It might just be me, but aside from Munson, I think all the sigs in black (the darker ones) might be clubhouse. The Nettles, Guidry and Dent seem off compared to IP ones I got back in those days.

[yanks12025]

Thanks guys for the help. Here's the last panel by the way.

[vintagechris]

It might just be me, but aside from Munson, I think all the sigs in black (the darker ones) might be clubhouse. The Nettles, Guidry and Dent seem off compared to IP ones I got back in those days.

Agree with this opinion 100%

[yanks12025]

Does the martin at least look good.

[Vintage Yankee]

Agree with this opinion 100%

+1

[MooseDog]

Thanks guys for the help. Here's the last panel by the way.

Same thing...the darker black ones don't seem right to me.

Don Hood...good (one of my all-time favorite sigs)
Chambliss...good
Doyle...looks off
Randoph...way off

[yanks12025]

Got the ball today even though I now know I paid too much. Here's a closer view of the Martin and the Jackson. Is either one good? The martin is a darker auto but compared to good Martin autos on team balls it looks like a match, but I'm not the expert... thanks

[Republicaninmass]

Martin looks close

[UnVme7]

Just my opinion, but I don't like the Martin auto either.

[Maddog]

The Randolph isn't even close to my IP ball.

[sycks22]

Kaat looks good

[mschwade]

Just my opinion, but I don't like the Martin auto either.

That surprises me, I actually think its good.

[UnVme7]

That surprises me, I actually think its good.

And it very well could be. It doesn't seem to match my 80's A's balls, but there might be a reason for that.

[UnVme7]

Here are some Billy Martin sweet spot examples. You can definitely tell a difference in the B in Billy and M in Martin.

Example 1

[UnVme7]

Example 2

[UnVme7]

Example 3

[UnVme7]

The posters ball

[yanks12025]

Nate,
Just curious why the three you post all seem to be signed differently. Are they clubhouse or real?

[UnVme7]

Nate,
Just curious why the three you post all seem to be signed differently. Are they clubhouse or real?

Don't they though? These all came from 3 different auctions. All of which were psa or jsa authenticated.

[UnVme7]

One of these has to be a clubhouse but neither auction mentions it. So never mind, I honestly don't know.